"When justice has spoken, humanity must have its turn"
About this Quote
Justice, in revolutionary France, is rarely a gentle noun. In Vergniaud's mouth it reads like a blade with a moral handle: first the law must assert itself, then compassion is permitted to enter the room. The line tries to impose sequence on chaos, to make political violence feel procedural rather than vengeful. It’s also a quiet warning to those who confuse punishment with virtue. Justice can speak in sentences; humanity speaks in mercy.
Vergniaud, a leading Girondin voice, was arguing in an atmosphere where tribunals and crowds competed to define righteousness. The Revolution had turned legitimacy into a moving target, and "justice" was being conscripted as a rhetorical badge for everything from reform to terror. By insisting that humanity "must have its turn", he frames compassion not as weakness but as a civic obligation deferred, not denied. That "must" matters: he is staking out a principle against the rising Jacobin appetite for permanent emergency.
The subtext is self-protective as well as ethical. Girondins believed the Revolution could survive only if it didn’t become an infinite loop of purges. Vergniaud’s phrasing suggests a society cannot live on verdicts alone; a republic that only condemns will eventually run out of citizens and call it purification. The bitter historical irony is that the line reads like a plea from inside the machinery that would soon execute him. In 1793, justice spoke loudly. Humanity never quite got its turn.
Vergniaud, a leading Girondin voice, was arguing in an atmosphere where tribunals and crowds competed to define righteousness. The Revolution had turned legitimacy into a moving target, and "justice" was being conscripted as a rhetorical badge for everything from reform to terror. By insisting that humanity "must have its turn", he frames compassion not as weakness but as a civic obligation deferred, not denied. That "must" matters: he is staking out a principle against the rising Jacobin appetite for permanent emergency.
The subtext is self-protective as well as ethical. Girondins believed the Revolution could survive only if it didn’t become an infinite loop of purges. Vergniaud’s phrasing suggests a society cannot live on verdicts alone; a republic that only condemns will eventually run out of citizens and call it purification. The bitter historical irony is that the line reads like a plea from inside the machinery that would soon execute him. In 1793, justice spoke loudly. Humanity never quite got its turn.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Pierre
Add to List









