"When new turns of behavior cease to appear in the life of the individual, its behavior ceases to be intelligent"
About this Quote
Intelligence, Carlyle implies, is less a possession than a performance: a living capacity to generate fresh moves when life changes the board. The line refuses the cozy Victorian notion of intellect as a stable endowment (the sort you can certify, inherit, or simply display). Instead, it makes intelligence conditional and time-sensitive. If you stop producing "new turns of behavior" - new responses, new experiments, new moral or practical adjustments - you may still be clever, educated, even brilliant in recall, but you are no longer intelligent in the only way that counts for survival: adaptive action.
The phrasing is doing quiet, muscular work. "Turns" suggests a chess match or a plot twist, which flatters the reader into seeing daily conduct as strategy rather than routine. "Ceases to appear" is colder than "stops" - it hints at a kind of disappearance, as if originality is a species that goes extinct inside a person. Carlyle's verb choice makes stagnation feel not like rest but like decay.
Context matters: Carlyle wrote in an era convulsed by industrialization, democratic agitation, and the unsettling replacement of inherited hierarchies with systems and machines. He distrusted mechanical thinking and dead formulae; he wanted "living" work, "living" faith, "living" heroes. Read that way, the quote is also a warning to a modernizing society: when institutions repeat themselves, when people outsource judgment to routine, intelligence becomes mere automation with a human face.
The phrasing is doing quiet, muscular work. "Turns" suggests a chess match or a plot twist, which flatters the reader into seeing daily conduct as strategy rather than routine. "Ceases to appear" is colder than "stops" - it hints at a kind of disappearance, as if originality is a species that goes extinct inside a person. Carlyle's verb choice makes stagnation feel not like rest but like decay.
Context matters: Carlyle wrote in an era convulsed by industrialization, democratic agitation, and the unsettling replacement of inherited hierarchies with systems and machines. He distrusted mechanical thinking and dead formulae; he wanted "living" work, "living" faith, "living" heroes. Read that way, the quote is also a warning to a modernizing society: when institutions repeat themselves, when people outsource judgment to routine, intelligence becomes mere automation with a human face.
Quote Details
| Topic | Change |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List







