"When shopping was still connected to the street it was also an intensification and articulation of the street. Now it has become utterly independent - contained, controlled, surveyed"
About this Quote
Koolhaas is mourning the death of a messy, democratic interface: the moment when commerce didn’t just sit on the street but actively edited it. “Intensification and articulation” is architect-speak with teeth. Shopping, in that older model, thickened public life: storefronts competed for attention, sidewalks turned into theaters, strangers negotiated space in real time. The street wasn’t a backdrop; it was a medium that retail amplified, sharpening the city’s rhythms and making urban experience legible.
Then comes the hard pivot: “utterly independent - contained, controlled, surveyed.” The dash reads like a scalpel. Koolhaas isn’t only describing the mall (or today’s big-box and lifestyle-center variants); he’s pointing at a governing logic that migrates from architecture into everyday life. Independence here doesn’t mean freedom. It means extraction: shopping removed from civic friction and reinstalled in a managed capsule, where circulation is engineered, behavior is predicted, and “public” space is privately administered.
The subtext is political as much as spatial. When retail detaches from the street, the city loses one of its most powerful engines of accidental encounter and informal oversight. What replaces it is a pseudo-urban set, built to simulate spontaneity while maximizing compliance and data capture. Koolhaas, long fascinated by congestion and spectacle, is also warning that the new spectacle is a quiet one: not the chaotic metropolis, but the seamless environment where your presence is welcomed primarily as a trackable transaction.
Then comes the hard pivot: “utterly independent - contained, controlled, surveyed.” The dash reads like a scalpel. Koolhaas isn’t only describing the mall (or today’s big-box and lifestyle-center variants); he’s pointing at a governing logic that migrates from architecture into everyday life. Independence here doesn’t mean freedom. It means extraction: shopping removed from civic friction and reinstalled in a managed capsule, where circulation is engineered, behavior is predicted, and “public” space is privately administered.
The subtext is political as much as spatial. When retail detaches from the street, the city loses one of its most powerful engines of accidental encounter and informal oversight. What replaces it is a pseudo-urban set, built to simulate spontaneity while maximizing compliance and data capture. Koolhaas, long fascinated by congestion and spectacle, is also warning that the new spectacle is a quiet one: not the chaotic metropolis, but the seamless environment where your presence is welcomed primarily as a trackable transaction.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Rem Koolhaas — "Junkspace" (essay). Contains the passage about shopping becoming "utterly independent — contained, controlled, surveyed." |
More Quotes by Rem
Add to List



