"When the music and the characters are flawlessly synchronized, the opera develops an emotional force that movies and plays cannot match"
About this Quote
Opera is the one art form that weaponizes timing. Beresford, a film director who lives and dies by editing rhythms, is admiring a medium where the cut is baked into the score. His line isn’t casual praise; it’s a challenge to his own craft. In movies, music is often an accessory: it sweetens, underlines, rescues. In opera, music is the engine that dictates breath, pace, and even psychological logic. When he says “flawlessly synchronized,” he’s talking about a rare, almost brutal alignment where character doesn’t just have a theme - character is the theme, moving on rails laid down by harmony and tempo.
The subtext is a quiet jab at the flexibility (and therefore the cheat codes) of film and theater. Cinema can swap takes, shift scenes, patch emotion in post. Plays can rely on naturalism and the actor’s spontaneity. Opera can’t fake it. If the music and drama aren’t fused, the whole thing collapses into pageantry or vocal athletics. But when they do fuse, the result feels inevitable, like emotion turned into physics: your body reacts before your intellect catches up.
Context matters here: Beresford comes from an era of directors raised on soundtrack-driven storytelling, yet he’s pointing to something older and less editable. He’s not claiming opera is “better.” He’s naming its competitive advantage: total integration, where narrative and sound hit the audience as a single blow.
The subtext is a quiet jab at the flexibility (and therefore the cheat codes) of film and theater. Cinema can swap takes, shift scenes, patch emotion in post. Plays can rely on naturalism and the actor’s spontaneity. Opera can’t fake it. If the music and drama aren’t fused, the whole thing collapses into pageantry or vocal athletics. But when they do fuse, the result feels inevitable, like emotion turned into physics: your body reacts before your intellect catches up.
Context matters here: Beresford comes from an era of directors raised on soundtrack-driven storytelling, yet he’s pointing to something older and less editable. He’s not claiming opera is “better.” He’s naming its competitive advantage: total integration, where narrative and sound hit the audience as a single blow.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Bruce
Add to List
