"When the people contend for their liberty, they seldom get anything by their victory but new masters"
About this Quote
Revolutions, Savile suggests, are astonishingly good at changing the names on the door and strangely bad at changing the room. In a single, cool sentence, he punctures the heroic storyline of “the people” rising and winning freedom by warning that victory often comes packaged as a personnel swap: old rulers out, new rulers in, same power dynamics intact.
The intent is not to scold liberty itself but to distrust the machinery that claims to deliver it. “Contend” implies struggle in the street and in parliament, the collective drama of a populace pushing against a regime. Savile’s sting lands on “seldom” and “anything but”: not never, but almost always; not partial disappointment, but a bleakly predictable outcome. The word “masters” is doing heavy work. It reduces politics to dominance and subordination, refusing the comforting euphemisms of “leaders” or “representatives.” Even a righteous cause can end with someone holding the whip.
Context matters: Savile was an 18th-century British politician watching a world where popular agitation, colonial unrest, and ideological ferment were colliding with entrenched elites. He’s writing from inside the governing class, which makes the line both shrewd and self-protective. It flatters the establishment’s favorite lesson: order is preferable to upheaval. At the same time, it’s a genuine diagnosis of how revolts get captured - by ambitious insiders, by charismatic strongmen, by institutions that survive by rebranding.
The subtext is a challenge to anyone chanting “freedom” without a plan for power: if you don’t redesign the system that produces masters, you’ll just audition for the next one.
The intent is not to scold liberty itself but to distrust the machinery that claims to deliver it. “Contend” implies struggle in the street and in parliament, the collective drama of a populace pushing against a regime. Savile’s sting lands on “seldom” and “anything but”: not never, but almost always; not partial disappointment, but a bleakly predictable outcome. The word “masters” is doing heavy work. It reduces politics to dominance and subordination, refusing the comforting euphemisms of “leaders” or “representatives.” Even a righteous cause can end with someone holding the whip.
Context matters: Savile was an 18th-century British politician watching a world where popular agitation, colonial unrest, and ideological ferment were colliding with entrenched elites. He’s writing from inside the governing class, which makes the line both shrewd and self-protective. It flatters the establishment’s favorite lesson: order is preferable to upheaval. At the same time, it’s a genuine diagnosis of how revolts get captured - by ambitious insiders, by charismatic strongmen, by institutions that survive by rebranding.
The subtext is a challenge to anyone chanting “freedom” without a plan for power: if you don’t redesign the system that produces masters, you’ll just audition for the next one.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by George
Add to List








