"When we began filming, these people had legs, but as we were filming, they had been injured and they were brought to the hospital to have their legs amputated, and that's where we found them and asked them to come and be part of the film"
About this Quote
The line lands with the deadpan shock of a documentary accident: a filmmaker describing catastrophe the way someone might describe a casting call. Makhmalbaf compresses an entire ethical crisis into a single, breathless timeline: first they had legs, then the shoot rolls on, then amputation, then recruitment. The grammar mimics the machinery of production, and that is the point. Cinema, in his telling, is always arriving late to reality and still insisting on turning it into material.
The intent isn’t cruelty so much as a bleak honesty about what his kind of filmmaking feeds on. Makhmalbaf comes out of Iranian cinema’s tradition of porous borders between fiction and nonfiction, where “real people” often play themselves and life isn’t just inspiration but raw footage. Here, the rawness is literal: injured bodies become the film’s proof of authenticity. The hospital becomes a set, the patients become performers, and the director becomes both witness and beneficiary of harm he didn’t cause but can’t pretend not to use.
The subtext is a provocation: if you demand realism, what are you willing to look at, and what will creators do to satisfy that demand? He’s also smuggling in a critique of spectatorship. Audiences want suffering to mean something, to be framed, paced, and given an arc. This quote refuses the comfort of distance. It makes the transaction visible: disaster happens, and art shows up with a release form.
The intent isn’t cruelty so much as a bleak honesty about what his kind of filmmaking feeds on. Makhmalbaf comes out of Iranian cinema’s tradition of porous borders between fiction and nonfiction, where “real people” often play themselves and life isn’t just inspiration but raw footage. Here, the rawness is literal: injured bodies become the film’s proof of authenticity. The hospital becomes a set, the patients become performers, and the director becomes both witness and beneficiary of harm he didn’t cause but can’t pretend not to use.
The subtext is a provocation: if you demand realism, what are you willing to look at, and what will creators do to satisfy that demand? He’s also smuggling in a critique of spectatorship. Audiences want suffering to mean something, to be framed, paced, and given an arc. This quote refuses the comfort of distance. It makes the transaction visible: disaster happens, and art shows up with a release form.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Mohsen
Add to List





