"When writing a novel a writer should create living people; people not characters. A character is a caricature"
About this Quote
Hemingway draws a hard line between inventing figures who perform functions on the page and imagining beings who seem to have existed before the first sentence and will continue after the last. Calling a character a caricature accuses the writer of flattening complexity into a single exaggerated trait. Caricature is useful for satire and sketching, but a novel asks the reader to live with people whose motives blur, whose actions contradict, and whose histories resist summary. The demand is not for eccentricity, but for the kind of density that real life confers: mixed loyalties, private shames, stray kindnesses, and the odd rhythms of speech.
That ideal runs through Hemingway’s craft. The spare sentences, the uncluttered dialogue, the famous iceberg principle all serve a moral preference for truth over display. By leaving much unsaid, he trusts the reader to sense the submerged mass of a life. Jake Barnes, Frederic Henry, Robert Jordan, and Santiago are not assembled from adjectives; they are revealed through choices under pressure, the weight of memory, and the dignity or failure of their acts. Their interiority is palpable not because the narrator explains them, but because they behave in ways that force us to infer what they cannot or will not articulate.
There is also a historical edge. Modernist fiction turned away from melodramatic plots and stock types that dominated much nineteenth-century storytelling. Having reported from wars and lived through dislocation, Hemingway distrusted tidy motives and theatrical speeches. He advocated observation, restraint, and fidelity to experience. The novelist, in that view, must watch closely, listen without preconception, and allow contradictions to stand without smoothing them into a theme.
The practical lesson is strict and liberating: do not label a figure brave or cruel; show the cost of an act and let the reader decide. Avoid the shorthand of archetype unless you intend satire. Seek the pulse of the ordinary, the gesture that betrays a secret, the silence that says more than confession. People, not puppets, make novels breathe.
That ideal runs through Hemingway’s craft. The spare sentences, the uncluttered dialogue, the famous iceberg principle all serve a moral preference for truth over display. By leaving much unsaid, he trusts the reader to sense the submerged mass of a life. Jake Barnes, Frederic Henry, Robert Jordan, and Santiago are not assembled from adjectives; they are revealed through choices under pressure, the weight of memory, and the dignity or failure of their acts. Their interiority is palpable not because the narrator explains them, but because they behave in ways that force us to infer what they cannot or will not articulate.
There is also a historical edge. Modernist fiction turned away from melodramatic plots and stock types that dominated much nineteenth-century storytelling. Having reported from wars and lived through dislocation, Hemingway distrusted tidy motives and theatrical speeches. He advocated observation, restraint, and fidelity to experience. The novelist, in that view, must watch closely, listen without preconception, and allow contradictions to stand without smoothing them into a theme.
The practical lesson is strict and liberating: do not label a figure brave or cruel; show the cost of an act and let the reader decide. Avoid the shorthand of archetype unless you intend satire. Seek the pulse of the ordinary, the gesture that betrays a secret, the silence that says more than confession. People, not puppets, make novels breathe.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Ernest
Add to List
