"When you do not know what you are doing and what you are doing is the best - that is inspiration"
About this Quote
Bresson frames inspiration as a kind of competent blindness: not ignorance as in amateurish flailing, but the moment when your conscious control falls behind the work and the work still lands. The line is built like a paradox on purpose. It yanks “best” away from the usual story we tell about mastery (planning, certainty, command) and ties it to a state closer to sleepwalking. That’s not mystical hand-waving; it’s a director describing the threshold where craft becomes instinct.
The subtext is anti-ego. If you “know what you are doing,” you’re often performing your own expertise, repeating solutions that already have a name. Bresson’s cinema is famous for stripping away that kind of knowing: nonprofessional actors (“models”), flattened delivery, gestures reduced to essentials, emotion created by omission. In that aesthetic, the director doesn’t manufacture feeling by force; he sets constraints so that something unpremeditated can slip through. Inspiration, here, isn’t a lightning bolt. It’s what happens when control loosens just enough for the image, the cut, or the performance to surprise even its maker.
Context matters: Bresson worked against the “quality” tradition of polished French filmmaking and against actorly expressiveness. His idea of the “best” is rarely the most decorated version of a scene; it’s the truest one, the one that hasn’t been over-explained. The quote doubles as a warning to artists intoxicated by their own intentions: if you can fully account for your choices, you may be making something legible, even impressive, but not alive.
The subtext is anti-ego. If you “know what you are doing,” you’re often performing your own expertise, repeating solutions that already have a name. Bresson’s cinema is famous for stripping away that kind of knowing: nonprofessional actors (“models”), flattened delivery, gestures reduced to essentials, emotion created by omission. In that aesthetic, the director doesn’t manufacture feeling by force; he sets constraints so that something unpremeditated can slip through. Inspiration, here, isn’t a lightning bolt. It’s what happens when control loosens just enough for the image, the cut, or the performance to surprise even its maker.
Context matters: Bresson worked against the “quality” tradition of polished French filmmaking and against actorly expressiveness. His idea of the “best” is rarely the most decorated version of a scene; it’s the truest one, the one that hasn’t been over-explained. The quote doubles as a warning to artists intoxicated by their own intentions: if you can fully account for your choices, you may be making something legible, even impressive, but not alive.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List






