"When you kill somebody in the movies, it matters, whereas in literature it can be allegorical"
About this Quote
Schroeder’s line is a quiet rebuke to the way we pretend violence on screen is “just a story.” Film kills with bodies: a face goes slack, blood has a color, the sound lands in your chest. Even when it’s staged, cinema insists on the physics of harm. That’s the “it matters” part - not a moral judgment so much as an aesthetic fact. The camera is an accomplice: it forces you to witness, and witnessing creates consequence.
Literature can do something film struggles to pull off without feeling coy: it can make a death function primarily as idea. A character can “die” as a metaphor for a nation, a faith, a phase of life, and the reader’s mind supplies the image on a sliding scale from abstract to intimate. The subtext here is about control and distance. On the page, the author can keep violence symbolic, or let it bloom slowly through language; in a movie, the director has to pick a body, pick a moment, pick the look of fear. The specificity collapses the alibi of allegory.
Coming from Schroeder, a filmmaker who’s moved between documentary textures and narrative shock (including films about real-world criminality), the remark also reads as a warning about medium ethics. Movies industrialize empathy and spectacle at the same time. They can make killing feel thrilling, clean, even stylish - but they can’t make it weightless. The image keeps its receipt.
Literature can do something film struggles to pull off without feeling coy: it can make a death function primarily as idea. A character can “die” as a metaphor for a nation, a faith, a phase of life, and the reader’s mind supplies the image on a sliding scale from abstract to intimate. The subtext here is about control and distance. On the page, the author can keep violence symbolic, or let it bloom slowly through language; in a movie, the director has to pick a body, pick a moment, pick the look of fear. The specificity collapses the alibi of allegory.
Coming from Schroeder, a filmmaker who’s moved between documentary textures and narrative shock (including films about real-world criminality), the remark also reads as a warning about medium ethics. Movies industrialize empathy and spectacle at the same time. They can make killing feel thrilling, clean, even stylish - but they can’t make it weightless. The image keeps its receipt.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|
More Quotes by Barbet
Add to List



