"When you look at Darling and the Oscars, it has to be luck. It was a black and white film and it was the last time that there was a black and white Oscar"
About this Quote
Luck is the polite word actors use when they don’t want to sound bitter about the machinery of taste. Julie Harris frames Darling’s Oscar moment as a kind of cosmic accident, but the subtext is sharper: awards aren’t just about merit, they’re about timing, fashion, and an industry’s shifting self-image.
Her detail work matters. “Black and white film” isn’t mere trivia; it’s a shorthand for a whole aesthetic regime Hollywood was actively abandoning in the mid-60s, when color had become both a technical standard and a marketing promise. By calling Darling “the last time” a black-and-white film won Best Picture, Harris turns an individual victory into a historical closing door. She’s not only remembering a win; she’s naming a pivot, the point where a certain kind of grown-up, metropolitan, morally restless cinema could still be crowned before spectacle and saturation took over as default prestige.
The move is also actorly: Harris casts herself as a clear-eyed witness, someone who knows how narratives get built after the fact. We love to retrofit inevitability onto Oscar history, as if the “best” naturally rises. Harris refuses that comforting myth. The line “it has to be luck” doubles as a critique of the Academy’s fickleness and a defense mechanism for artists who’ve watched equally strong work vanish because it didn’t match the mood of the room.
Contextually, it’s a reminder that cultural institutions don’t just reward art; they ratify eras.
Her detail work matters. “Black and white film” isn’t mere trivia; it’s a shorthand for a whole aesthetic regime Hollywood was actively abandoning in the mid-60s, when color had become both a technical standard and a marketing promise. By calling Darling “the last time” a black-and-white film won Best Picture, Harris turns an individual victory into a historical closing door. She’s not only remembering a win; she’s naming a pivot, the point where a certain kind of grown-up, metropolitan, morally restless cinema could still be crowned before spectacle and saturation took over as default prestige.
The move is also actorly: Harris casts herself as a clear-eyed witness, someone who knows how narratives get built after the fact. We love to retrofit inevitability onto Oscar history, as if the “best” naturally rises. Harris refuses that comforting myth. The line “it has to be luck” doubles as a critique of the Academy’s fickleness and a defense mechanism for artists who’ve watched equally strong work vanish because it didn’t match the mood of the room.
Contextually, it’s a reminder that cultural institutions don’t just reward art; they ratify eras.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|
More Quotes by Julie
Add to List
