"Whenever I felt happy about having discovered something, the first encounter, not only with the public, with other musicians, with specialists, etc, was that they rejected it"
About this Quote
Joy, for Stockhausen, is the telltale symptom of exile. The line turns the romantic image of the inspired composer on its head: discovery isn’t validated by applause but by the chill of immediate rejection. He’s describing a pattern that defined postwar European modernism, when new sounds arrived like foreign objects in concert halls still trained to crave melody, sentiment, and the reassuring grammar of the 19th century. If you were building music out of radio static, sine waves, and serialized parameters, “happy” wasn’t a victory lap; it was a private ignition before the world’s fireproofing kicked in.
The sting here is how broad the resistance is: not just “the public” (easy villain), but “other musicians” and “specialists.” Stockhausen is pointing to a gatekeeping ecosystem that punishes aesthetic risk at every level, including the people paid to understand it. The subtext isn’t merely martyrdom; it’s a critique of professional listening, the way expertise can calcify into consensus and treat the unfamiliar as an error rather than a proposal.
There’s also a psychological tell. He frames discovery as “first encounter,” like a new organism being introduced to a hostile environment. That phrasing suggests he expects rejection as part of the work’s lifecycle, almost as proof of concept: if it doesn’t shock, it probably isn’t new enough. In Stockhausen’s world, innovation is a social conflict before it’s a musical one, and the composer learns to measure progress by resistance.
The sting here is how broad the resistance is: not just “the public” (easy villain), but “other musicians” and “specialists.” Stockhausen is pointing to a gatekeeping ecosystem that punishes aesthetic risk at every level, including the people paid to understand it. The subtext isn’t merely martyrdom; it’s a critique of professional listening, the way expertise can calcify into consensus and treat the unfamiliar as an error rather than a proposal.
There’s also a psychological tell. He frames discovery as “first encounter,” like a new organism being introduced to a hostile environment. That phrasing suggests he expects rejection as part of the work’s lifecycle, almost as proof of concept: if it doesn’t shock, it probably isn’t new enough. In Stockhausen’s world, innovation is a social conflict before it’s a musical one, and the composer learns to measure progress by resistance.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Karlheinz
Add to List

