"Where the whole man is involved there is no work. Work begins with the division of labor"
About this Quote
McLuhan’s line slices straight through the warm bath of “do what you love” rhetoric and reminds you that modern work is, by design, a form of partial living. “Where the whole man is involved” conjures an older ideal: craft, ritual, or calling where mind, body, and identity are all on the line. In that state, the activity doesn’t feel like “work” because it isn’t alienated from the self; it’s inseparable from purpose, community, and consequence. The sting comes in the pivot: work begins when the person is broken into functions.
The intent is diagnostic, not nostalgic. McLuhan isn’t merely praising artisans; he’s naming a cultural technology. Division of labor isn’t just an economic arrangement, it’s a psychic one: it trains people to experience themselves as interchangeable parts. The subtext is grimly contemporary: if you’re exhausted by tasks that feel abstract, metric-driven, and oddly disposable, that’s not a personal failure of passion. It’s the system doing what it was built to do - convert full human capacities into discrete, manageable outputs.
Context matters. Writing in the mid-20th century, McLuhan watched mass media, automation, and bureaucratic institutions reorganize perception itself. His broader project was to show how environments shape us more than individual content does. Here, “work” is an environment: a way of carving up attention, time, and identity so efficiently that wholeness becomes almost illegible. The quote works because it flips a moral category into a structural one: the problem isn’t laziness or virtue, it’s how society decides what counts as a person.
The intent is diagnostic, not nostalgic. McLuhan isn’t merely praising artisans; he’s naming a cultural technology. Division of labor isn’t just an economic arrangement, it’s a psychic one: it trains people to experience themselves as interchangeable parts. The subtext is grimly contemporary: if you’re exhausted by tasks that feel abstract, metric-driven, and oddly disposable, that’s not a personal failure of passion. It’s the system doing what it was built to do - convert full human capacities into discrete, manageable outputs.
Context matters. Writing in the mid-20th century, McLuhan watched mass media, automation, and bureaucratic institutions reorganize perception itself. His broader project was to show how environments shape us more than individual content does. Here, “work” is an environment: a way of carving up attention, time, and identity so efficiently that wholeness becomes almost illegible. The quote works because it flips a moral category into a structural one: the problem isn’t laziness or virtue, it’s how society decides what counts as a person.
Quote Details
| Topic | Work |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Marshall
Add to List








