"Where there had been only jeers or taunts at first, crowds come to listen with serious and sympathetic men"
About this Quote
It is the hinge-moment every dissident hopes for: the crowd stops performing contempt and starts doing something rarer, riskier, and more human - listening. Carpenter is charting a social conversion, not a personal one. The line begins in the theater of public cruelty ("jeers or taunts"), where ridicule functions as enforcement. Mockery is how a majority polices its borders without needing a law: it marks certain people and ideas as unfit for serious consideration. Then the mood shifts. Crowds "come to listen" - the verb suggests motion, a chosen approach, as if curiosity has finally overpowered reflex.
The most revealing word is "men". Carpenter, writing as a socialist, pacifist, and early advocate for homosexual rights, knew his audiences were often male-dominated forums: union halls, street meetings, lecture circuits. The phrase "serious and sympathetic" is doing double duty. It signals moral maturation (seriousness as responsibility) and emotional expansion (sympathy as recognition). Subtext: you cannot win an argument about human dignity if the room is committed to laughing you out of it; you win when laughter becomes socially embarrassing.
Historically, Carpenter’s Britain is thick with this dynamic. Late Victorian and Edwardian reformers faced hecklers, hostile press, and moral panic. Public opinion moved slowly, in fits - first treating radicals and "inverts" as jokes, then as threats, and only occasionally as neighbors. Carpenter is describing the fragile moment when a movement breaks past spectacle into legitimacy, when the crowd’s attention becomes a form of protection. Listening, here, isn’t passive. It’s the first act of solidarity.
The most revealing word is "men". Carpenter, writing as a socialist, pacifist, and early advocate for homosexual rights, knew his audiences were often male-dominated forums: union halls, street meetings, lecture circuits. The phrase "serious and sympathetic" is doing double duty. It signals moral maturation (seriousness as responsibility) and emotional expansion (sympathy as recognition). Subtext: you cannot win an argument about human dignity if the room is committed to laughing you out of it; you win when laughter becomes socially embarrassing.
Historically, Carpenter’s Britain is thick with this dynamic. Late Victorian and Edwardian reformers faced hecklers, hostile press, and moral panic. Public opinion moved slowly, in fits - first treating radicals and "inverts" as jokes, then as threats, and only occasionally as neighbors. Carpenter is describing the fragile moment when a movement breaks past spectacle into legitimacy, when the crowd’s attention becomes a form of protection. Listening, here, isn’t passive. It’s the first act of solidarity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List
