"Wherever there is interest and power to do wrong, wrong will generally be done"
About this Quote
Madison’s line is the anti-fairytale version of governance: if temptation meets capacity, don’t bet on virtue. It’s not cynicism for sport; it’s a design brief. Coming from a chief architect of the Constitution, the sentence quietly rejects the era’s more optimistic faith that enlightened leaders, republican culture, or “good men” could carry a system on their backs. Madison is treating wrongdoing as predictable behavior under certain conditions, not a shocking moral failure. That shift matters: it turns politics from a sermon into an engineering problem.
The phrasing is surgical. “Interest” points to self-preservation, profit, faction, careerism - the ordinary motives that feel rational from the inside. “Power to do wrong” is the enabling condition: unchecked authority, secrecy, monopoly over force, or institutions too weak to impose costs. Put them together and “generally” does the heavy lifting. Madison isn’t claiming everyone is corrupt; he’s claiming you can’t build a stable republic on exceptions. A system that relies on moral heroism is a system that will eventually meet ordinary humans and fail.
Contextually, this logic sits inside the Founding argument for checks and balances, divided power, and ambition counteracting ambition. The subtext is a warning to citizens as much as to rulers: don’t confuse a leader’s rhetoric with a safeguard. Assume incentives, not intentions, will run the show. Madison’s bleak realism is also oddly democratic - it levels the playing field. If wrongdoing is a feature of opportunity, the fix isn’t purity tests; it’s constraints, transparency, and institutions that make “doing wrong” harder, riskier, and less rewarding.
The phrasing is surgical. “Interest” points to self-preservation, profit, faction, careerism - the ordinary motives that feel rational from the inside. “Power to do wrong” is the enabling condition: unchecked authority, secrecy, monopoly over force, or institutions too weak to impose costs. Put them together and “generally” does the heavy lifting. Madison isn’t claiming everyone is corrupt; he’s claiming you can’t build a stable republic on exceptions. A system that relies on moral heroism is a system that will eventually meet ordinary humans and fail.
Contextually, this logic sits inside the Founding argument for checks and balances, divided power, and ambition counteracting ambition. The subtext is a warning to citizens as much as to rulers: don’t confuse a leader’s rhetoric with a safeguard. Assume incentives, not intentions, will run the show. Madison’s bleak realism is also oddly democratic - it levels the playing field. If wrongdoing is a feature of opportunity, the fix isn’t purity tests; it’s constraints, transparency, and institutions that make “doing wrong” harder, riskier, and less rewarding.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by James
Add to List





