"Whether something is old-fashioned or not doesn't resolve the question of whether it's true or not. I can see the temptation of simply thinking, 'Well, there's a cultural mainstream which flows neatly in one direction. You just align with it'. And that really won't do"
About this Quote
His phrasing does a lot of work. “Doesn’t resolve the question” sounds almost bureaucratic, like a judge dismissing irrelevant evidence. That restraint is part of the argument. Williams isn’t pitching nostalgia; he’s challenging epistemology. Truth, in his view, isn’t decided by trendlines. Calling something “old-fashioned” is a social maneuver, not a refutation. It lets you win without arguing.
The subtext is aimed at institutions - churches, universities, political parties - that feel squeezed between inherited doctrine and shifting public consensus. “Cultural mainstream… flows neatly in one direction” caricatures the story progressives tell themselves when they’re least curious: that there’s a single river of progress, and dissent is just backwardness. “You just align with it” names the temptation of moral outsourcing, the seductive relief of letting the crowd do your thinking.
“And that really won’t do” is vintage Williams: understated, almost pastoral, but firm. It suggests a deeper ethical demand - to test beliefs by reasons, consequences, and coherence, not by their date stamp. In a culture that confuses momentum with morality, he’s insisting on the harder discipline: judgment.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Williams, Rowan. (2026, January 15). Whether something is old-fashioned or not doesn't resolve the question of whether it's true or not. I can see the temptation of simply thinking, 'Well, there's a cultural mainstream which flows neatly in one direction. You just align with it'. And that really won't do. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/whether-something-is-old-fashioned-or-not-doesnt-21754/
Chicago Style
Williams, Rowan. "Whether something is old-fashioned or not doesn't resolve the question of whether it's true or not. I can see the temptation of simply thinking, 'Well, there's a cultural mainstream which flows neatly in one direction. You just align with it'. And that really won't do." FixQuotes. January 15, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/whether-something-is-old-fashioned-or-not-doesnt-21754/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Whether something is old-fashioned or not doesn't resolve the question of whether it's true or not. I can see the temptation of simply thinking, 'Well, there's a cultural mainstream which flows neatly in one direction. You just align with it'. And that really won't do." FixQuotes, 15 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/whether-something-is-old-fashioned-or-not-doesnt-21754/. Accessed 12 Feb. 2026.





