"While I do not suggest that humanity will ever be able to dispense with its martyrs, I cannot avoid the suspicion that with a little more thought and a little less belief their number may be substantially reduced"
About this Quote
Haldane is doing something scientists do best: puncturing a cherished story without pretending he can abolish it. The line concedes a bleak constant - societies seem to require martyrs the way engines require friction - then quietly indicts the machinery that produces them. The key move is in the pairing: "a little more thought and a little less belief". Thought here isn’t just intelligence; it’s skepticism, method, the habit of checking whether a sacrifice is necessary or merely narratively satisfying. Belief isn’t faith as comfort but belief as accelerant: conviction that outruns evidence, turning disagreement into heresy and error into treason.
The intent is reformist, not utopian. He doesn’t promise an enlightened future free of blood; he’s targeting the preventable surplus. That’s the subtextual sting: most martyrs are not inevitable victims of fate but products of intellectual laziness and social incentives. Martyrdom becomes a managed resource, replenished by institutions that benefit from purity tests, holy causes, and the spectacle of suffering.
Context matters: Haldane was a working scientist and public intellectual in a century that industrialized martyr-making - from world wars to ideological purges. He also lived near the border where science itself becomes creed, and where dissenters (or heretics) can be manufactured on either side. The sentence is wryly calibrated: modest verbs ("do not suggest", "cannot avoid the suspicion") smuggle a radical claim past defenses. If we treated ideas less like identities and more like hypotheses, we’d still have tragedy, but less of the needless kind we mistake for destiny.
The intent is reformist, not utopian. He doesn’t promise an enlightened future free of blood; he’s targeting the preventable surplus. That’s the subtextual sting: most martyrs are not inevitable victims of fate but products of intellectual laziness and social incentives. Martyrdom becomes a managed resource, replenished by institutions that benefit from purity tests, holy causes, and the spectacle of suffering.
Context matters: Haldane was a working scientist and public intellectual in a century that industrialized martyr-making - from world wars to ideological purges. He also lived near the border where science itself becomes creed, and where dissenters (or heretics) can be manufactured on either side. The sentence is wryly calibrated: modest verbs ("do not suggest", "cannot avoid the suspicion") smuggle a radical claim past defenses. If we treated ideas less like identities and more like hypotheses, we’d still have tragedy, but less of the needless kind we mistake for destiny.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List
