"While many people think that we as reporters are whining and that this is a time of war, we are really the conveyors of truth in a very critical time and people need to know that truth"
About this Quote
Rose is pushing back against a familiar wartime reflex: treat scrutiny as disloyalty, treat questions as noise. The line is built like a rebuttal to a heckler. He starts with the accusation reporters hear in real time - “whining,” a word that infantilizes the press and recasts accountability as self-pity. Pair it with “this is a time of war” and you get the implied gag order: emergencies demand unity, unity demands silence.
His counter-claim doesn’t romanticize journalism as heroism so much as necessity. “Conveyors of truth” is deliberately unglamorous, almost industrial. Not prophets, not activists, not performers - a channel. That choice is strategic: it frames reporting as infrastructure for democracy, the civic equivalent of water lines and power grids. In wartime, when propaganda, rumor, and fear compete to become policy, “conveying” becomes an act with consequences: whose deaths are counted, whose mistakes are hidden, whose story becomes the official one.
The subtext is also defensive, aware of a post-Vietnam, post-Watergate culture where the press is both lionized and blamed. Rose anticipates the charge that journalists are centering themselves during crisis. He answers by shifting the spotlight to the public: “people need to know.” That last clause is the moral lever. It reframes truth not as a luxury or a political preference, but as a wartime requirement - because consent, sacrifice, and strategy mean nothing if citizens are operating on curated narratives.
His counter-claim doesn’t romanticize journalism as heroism so much as necessity. “Conveyors of truth” is deliberately unglamorous, almost industrial. Not prophets, not activists, not performers - a channel. That choice is strategic: it frames reporting as infrastructure for democracy, the civic equivalent of water lines and power grids. In wartime, when propaganda, rumor, and fear compete to become policy, “conveying” becomes an act with consequences: whose deaths are counted, whose mistakes are hidden, whose story becomes the official one.
The subtext is also defensive, aware of a post-Vietnam, post-Watergate culture where the press is both lionized and blamed. Rose anticipates the charge that journalists are centering themselves during crisis. He answers by shifting the spotlight to the public: “people need to know.” That last clause is the moral lever. It reframes truth not as a luxury or a political preference, but as a wartime requirement - because consent, sacrifice, and strategy mean nothing if citizens are operating on curated narratives.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Judd
Add to List
