"While that amendment failed, human cloning continues to advance and the breakthrough in this unethical and morally questionable science is around the corner"
About this Quote
Pence’s line is built like a campaign ad in miniature: a setback, a ticking clock, a villain, and a moral summons. “While that amendment failed” opens with grievance and urgency, implying a responsible guardrail was rejected and someone must be blamed. Then comes the accelerant: “continues to advance,” “breakthrough,” “around the corner.” The science is framed less as a field than as an oncoming vehicle, fast and nearly here, which turns legislative action into an emergency rather than a debate.
The real work happens in the adjectives. By calling cloning “unethical and morally questionable,” he doubles the charge, collapsing complex biomedical arguments into a single moral verdict. The phrase doesn’t just condemn an outcome; it delegitimizes the enterprise itself, turning researchers into suspects and regulation into rescue. That’s strategic: if the practice is inherently corrupt, you don’t need to parse distinctions like therapeutic cloning versus reproductive cloning, or governance versus prohibition.
Context matters. Pence is speaking from within a US conservative coalition where abortion politics, stem-cell research, and “playing God” anxieties overlap. “Amendment” signals a fight to constitutionalize a moral boundary, not merely pass a statute. The subtext is cultural authority: modernity is moving too fast, elites are unaccountable, and only clear moral lines can protect human dignity. It’s less a warning about cloning than a bid to define who gets to speak for “the human” in a technological age.
The real work happens in the adjectives. By calling cloning “unethical and morally questionable,” he doubles the charge, collapsing complex biomedical arguments into a single moral verdict. The phrase doesn’t just condemn an outcome; it delegitimizes the enterprise itself, turning researchers into suspects and regulation into rescue. That’s strategic: if the practice is inherently corrupt, you don’t need to parse distinctions like therapeutic cloning versus reproductive cloning, or governance versus prohibition.
Context matters. Pence is speaking from within a US conservative coalition where abortion politics, stem-cell research, and “playing God” anxieties overlap. “Amendment” signals a fight to constitutionalize a moral boundary, not merely pass a statute. The subtext is cultural authority: modernity is moving too fast, elites are unaccountable, and only clear moral lines can protect human dignity. It’s less a warning about cloning than a bid to define who gets to speak for “the human” in a technological age.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Mike
Add to List
