"Who do I think was the greatest? This might shock you: Elgin Baylor. He did so many great things. Nobody could guard him, playing in the forward spot. I'd love to see some of today's greats playing against Elgin. They couldn't guard him. Nobody could"
About this Quote
The insistence on “nobody could guard him” reads like more than praise. It’s a demand that we take Baylor’s dominance seriously on its own terms, not as a sepia-toned footnote. Robertson frames Baylor as a mismatch problem that transcends eras, and the repetition (“They couldn’t… Nobody could”) functions like a drumbeat: stop arguing hypotheticals, start respecting evidence.
There’s also a quiet correction embedded in the position talk. By emphasizing Baylor “playing in the forward spot,” Robertson points to how Baylor bent the role before “positionless basketball” became a buzzword. Baylor’s blend of power and air-time prefigured modern wing play; Robertson is basically saying the league didn’t invent athletic, creative forwards in the 2010s.
Context matters: Robertson and Baylor were peers in a time when players had less media machinery and fewer highlight reels to keep them immortal. This is an elder statesman using credibility to re-rank the pantheon and challenge today’s fans to watch past the algorithm.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sports |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Robertson, Oscar. (2026, January 16). Who do I think was the greatest? This might shock you: Elgin Baylor. He did so many great things. Nobody could guard him, playing in the forward spot. I'd love to see some of today's greats playing against Elgin. They couldn't guard him. Nobody could. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/who-do-i-think-was-the-greatest-this-might-shock-94355/
Chicago Style
Robertson, Oscar. "Who do I think was the greatest? This might shock you: Elgin Baylor. He did so many great things. Nobody could guard him, playing in the forward spot. I'd love to see some of today's greats playing against Elgin. They couldn't guard him. Nobody could." FixQuotes. January 16, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/who-do-i-think-was-the-greatest-this-might-shock-94355/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Who do I think was the greatest? This might shock you: Elgin Baylor. He did so many great things. Nobody could guard him, playing in the forward spot. I'd love to see some of today's greats playing against Elgin. They couldn't guard him. Nobody could." FixQuotes, 16 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/who-do-i-think-was-the-greatest-this-might-shock-94355/. Accessed 22 Feb. 2026.



