"Who knows where inspiration comes from. Perhaps it arises from desperation. Perhaps it comes from the flukes of the universe, the kindness of the muses"
About this Quote
Amy Tan’s line refuses the tidy mythology of the writer as someone visited on schedule by a benevolent, scented “muse.” It’s an admission of craft lived in the real world: inspiration isn’t a credential, it’s a weather system. By stacking “Perhaps” against “Perhaps,” Tan builds a rhythm of uncertainty that feels earned rather than coy. The sentence keeps opening doors instead of closing them, which is exactly how creative work often feels from the inside - less revelation than groping.
The real pivot is her pairing of desperation with cosmic luck. Desperation suggests urgency, constraint, a problem you can’t escape until you make meaning out of it. That’s a deeply immigrant-and-family-stories kind of pressure, resonant with Tan’s fiction: private histories, generational misunderstandings, the need to translate pain into narrative because silence is its own kind of loss. When inspiration “arises” from desperation, it’s not romantic; it’s adaptive. You write because you have to.
Then she flips to “the flukes of the universe,” a phrase that punctures artistic ego. If a good idea might be a fluke, authorship becomes less a heroic identity and more a collaboration with randomness - overheard dialogue, misremembered details, the accident that unlocks a scene. Ending on “the kindness of the muses” keeps one foot in the old metaphor, but “kindness” makes it feel modest, almost skeptical: muses aren’t masters, they’re occasional allies. Tan’s intent is permission-giving - to keep working even when the source can’t be explained, and to accept that mystery without turning it into a brand.
The real pivot is her pairing of desperation with cosmic luck. Desperation suggests urgency, constraint, a problem you can’t escape until you make meaning out of it. That’s a deeply immigrant-and-family-stories kind of pressure, resonant with Tan’s fiction: private histories, generational misunderstandings, the need to translate pain into narrative because silence is its own kind of loss. When inspiration “arises” from desperation, it’s not romantic; it’s adaptive. You write because you have to.
Then she flips to “the flukes of the universe,” a phrase that punctures artistic ego. If a good idea might be a fluke, authorship becomes less a heroic identity and more a collaboration with randomness - overheard dialogue, misremembered details, the accident that unlocks a scene. Ending on “the kindness of the muses” keeps one foot in the old metaphor, but “kindness” makes it feel modest, almost skeptical: muses aren’t masters, they’re occasional allies. Tan’s intent is permission-giving - to keep working even when the source can’t be explained, and to accept that mystery without turning it into a brand.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Amy
Add to List







