"Who's to say who's an expert?"
About this Quote
"Who's to say who's an expert?" lands like a shrug with teeth. Coming from Paul Newman, it’s not anti-intellectualism so much as a practiced suspicion of gatekeepers - the people who anoint authority, then treat that anointment as proof. Newman spent a career in an industry where "expertise" is constantly performed: critics declare meaning, studios market prestige, actors are praised for "range" as if it’s a measurable unit. The line pokes at that whole ecosystem, where credentials often trail behind confidence.
The brilliance is the recursive trap in the wording. It doesn’t argue that experts don’t exist; it asks who gets to certify them. That forces the listener to notice the hidden scaffolding behind every expert label: institutions, access, networks, taste-making, even money. Newman’s movie-star persona matters here. He was both an insider and, famously, someone who cultivated outsider credibility - the cool, plainspoken guy who looks allergic to self-importance. When he questions expertise, it reads less like a rant and more like a recalibration: don’t confuse the microphone with wisdom.
There’s also a democratic instinct in it, the kind that fits a celebrity who later put serious energy into philanthropy and activism. Expertise can be real and still be political. Newman’s line reminds you that authority isn’t only earned; it’s granted, defended, and sometimes sold.
The brilliance is the recursive trap in the wording. It doesn’t argue that experts don’t exist; it asks who gets to certify them. That forces the listener to notice the hidden scaffolding behind every expert label: institutions, access, networks, taste-making, even money. Newman’s movie-star persona matters here. He was both an insider and, famously, someone who cultivated outsider credibility - the cool, plainspoken guy who looks allergic to self-importance. When he questions expertise, it reads less like a rant and more like a recalibration: don’t confuse the microphone with wisdom.
There’s also a democratic instinct in it, the kind that fits a celebrity who later put serious energy into philanthropy and activism. Expertise can be real and still be political. Newman’s line reminds you that authority isn’t only earned; it’s granted, defended, and sometimes sold.
Quote Details
| Topic | Knowledge |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Newman, Paul. (2026, January 15). Who's to say who's an expert? FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/whos-to-say-whos-an-expert-164383/
Chicago Style
Newman, Paul. "Who's to say who's an expert?" FixQuotes. January 15, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/whos-to-say-whos-an-expert-164383/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Who's to say who's an expert?" FixQuotes, 15 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/whos-to-say-whos-an-expert-164383/. Accessed 16 Feb. 2026.
More Quotes by Paul
Add to List






