"Why should the composer be more guilty than the poet who warms to fantasy by a strange flame, making an idea that inspires him the subject of his own very different treatment?"
About this Quote
The phrasing is the tell. “Warms to fantasy by a strange flame” romanticizes inspiration as involuntary combustion, not calculated borrowing. That metaphor quietly absolves the artist: the impulse is elemental, not litigious. Then Schubert lands the real argument in the final clause: “his own very different treatment.” Originality isn’t the raw ingredient; it’s the transformation. He’s staking out a modern-sounding definition of authorship based on process and interpretation, not on owning a premise.
There’s also a classed subtext. Poetry enjoyed prestige as “high” art; instrumental and song composition, especially when tied to popular tunes or earlier models, could be dismissed as craft. Schubert is insisting that musical imagination is not a secondary language. The composer’s “guilt” is a social construction, born from critics and gatekeepers who treat influence as evidence of deficiency. He’s arguing for a creative commons before the term existed: the artistic act is not mining untouched territory, but making something unmistakably yours out of what culture has already set alight.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Schubert, Franz. (2026, January 16). Why should the composer be more guilty than the poet who warms to fantasy by a strange flame, making an idea that inspires him the subject of his own very different treatment? FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/why-should-the-composer-be-more-guilty-than-the-91269/
Chicago Style
Schubert, Franz. "Why should the composer be more guilty than the poet who warms to fantasy by a strange flame, making an idea that inspires him the subject of his own very different treatment?" FixQuotes. January 16, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/why-should-the-composer-be-more-guilty-than-the-91269/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Why should the composer be more guilty than the poet who warms to fantasy by a strange flame, making an idea that inspires him the subject of his own very different treatment?" FixQuotes, 16 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/why-should-the-composer-be-more-guilty-than-the-91269/. Accessed 12 Feb. 2026.








