Skip to main content

Daily Inspiration Quote by Franz Schubert

"Why should the composer be more guilty than the poet who warms to fantasy by a strange flame, making an idea that inspires him the subject of his own very different treatment?"

About this Quote

Schubert is doing something sly here: he’s not defending theft so much as puncturing the moral panic around it. The line comes out of a long 19th-century anxiety about originality, an era when “genius” was starting to harden into a near-religious ideal, even as artists freely borrowed themes, forms, and folk material. He flips the accusation with a clean analogy: if poets are allowed to take an idea, catch fire, and remake it, why is a composer treated as the criminal cousin for doing the same?

The phrasing is the tell. “Warms to fantasy by a strange flame” romanticizes inspiration as involuntary combustion, not calculated borrowing. That metaphor quietly absolves the artist: the impulse is elemental, not litigious. Then Schubert lands the real argument in the final clause: “his own very different treatment.” Originality isn’t the raw ingredient; it’s the transformation. He’s staking out a modern-sounding definition of authorship based on process and interpretation, not on owning a premise.

There’s also a classed subtext. Poetry enjoyed prestige as “high” art; instrumental and song composition, especially when tied to popular tunes or earlier models, could be dismissed as craft. Schubert is insisting that musical imagination is not a secondary language. The composer’s “guilt” is a social construction, born from critics and gatekeepers who treat influence as evidence of deficiency. He’s arguing for a creative commons before the term existed: the artistic act is not mining untouched territory, but making something unmistakably yours out of what culture has already set alight.

Quote Details

TopicMusic
More Quotes by Franz Add to List
Schubert on Musical Adaptation and Artistic Transformation
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

Austria Flag

Franz Schubert (January 31, 1797 - November 19, 1828) was a Composer from Austria.

23 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes