"Why should we put ourselves out of our way to do anything for posterity? For what has posterity ever done for us?"
About this Quote
Posterity is usually invoked as a moral referee: behave well today so history will applaud you tomorrow. Boyle Roche flips that piety into a deadpan grievance, treating “posterity” like a freeloading neighbor who never pays rent. The joke lands because it drags an abstract ideal down to the level of transactional politics. If the future can’t vote, can’t donate, can’t deliver patronage, why cater to it?
Roche was an Irish politician in the late 18th century, a world where public virtue often came packaged with private advantage and where the machinery of government rewarded loyalty in the present tense. Read in that light, the line isn’t just a gag; it’s a little act of sabotage against high-minded rhetoric. It punctures the comforting story that leaders are selflessly building “for our children.” The subtext is that political speech is full of grand nouns - nation, destiny, posterity - that function as cover for immediate interests.
What makes it work is the faux-reasonable tone. Roche doesn’t rant about corruption; he asks a question that sounds like common sense, then answers it with a punchline that exposes the premise: we often justify sacrifice by imagining future gratitude, even though gratitude is unenforceable. There’s also a darker insinuation: if politicians are only moved by direct return, the social contract collapses into short-term deals. Roche’s quip is funny because it’s petty; it’s unsettling because it’s plausible.
Roche was an Irish politician in the late 18th century, a world where public virtue often came packaged with private advantage and where the machinery of government rewarded loyalty in the present tense. Read in that light, the line isn’t just a gag; it’s a little act of sabotage against high-minded rhetoric. It punctures the comforting story that leaders are selflessly building “for our children.” The subtext is that political speech is full of grand nouns - nation, destiny, posterity - that function as cover for immediate interests.
What makes it work is the faux-reasonable tone. Roche doesn’t rant about corruption; he asks a question that sounds like common sense, then answers it with a punchline that exposes the premise: we often justify sacrifice by imagining future gratitude, even though gratitude is unenforceable. There’s also a darker insinuation: if politicians are only moved by direct return, the social contract collapses into short-term deals. Roche’s quip is funny because it’s petty; it’s unsettling because it’s plausible.
Quote Details
| Topic | Legacy & Remembrance |
|---|---|
| Source | Attributed to Boyle Roche (1736–1807). Quotation appears in collections of his reported remarks; see Wikiquote entry for citation and context. |
More Quotes by Boyle
Add to List









