"Why shouldn't rap be esoteric, able to take in current events, history and criticism? I guess it's this old idea of containment - that rappers, because they're black, can't and shouldn't aspire to look outside the ghetto for influence"
About this Quote
Williams treats rap like a library that keeps getting mistaken for a cage. The first line is a challenge disguised as a shrug: why not let rap be as dense, referential, and argumentative as any “serious” art? He’s pushing back against the patronizing expectation that hip-hop must stay legible on command, translated into struggle narratives for outsiders, never too bookish, never too wide-ranging, never “difficult” in the way rock or indie poets are allowed to be.
The subtext is about who gets to be complicated. “Esoteric” isn’t a flex here; it’s a demand for artistic sovereignty. When Williams says rap should “take in current events, history and criticism,” he’s naming rap’s existing capacities while calling out the gatekeeping that pretends those capacities are off-brand. The real target is the cultural management of Black expression: the industry’s profit motive, the media’s stereotypes, and a liberal curiosity that applauds authenticity as long as it comes prepackaged as poverty reportage.
“Containment” is the key word, echoing not just racial segregation but a softer, modern form: aesthetic segregation. The ghetto becomes both a real place and a metaphorical assignment. Williams, emerging from the late-90s/early-2000s spoken-word and alternative hip-hop ecosystem, is arguing for permission that should never have to be granted: the right for Black artists to be influenced by philosophy, punk, world politics, and criticism without being accused of betrayal or “trying to be white.”
It works because it flips the burden of explanation. The question isn’t why rap should expand; it’s why anyone wants it fenced in.
The subtext is about who gets to be complicated. “Esoteric” isn’t a flex here; it’s a demand for artistic sovereignty. When Williams says rap should “take in current events, history and criticism,” he’s naming rap’s existing capacities while calling out the gatekeeping that pretends those capacities are off-brand. The real target is the cultural management of Black expression: the industry’s profit motive, the media’s stereotypes, and a liberal curiosity that applauds authenticity as long as it comes prepackaged as poverty reportage.
“Containment” is the key word, echoing not just racial segregation but a softer, modern form: aesthetic segregation. The ghetto becomes both a real place and a metaphorical assignment. Williams, emerging from the late-90s/early-2000s spoken-word and alternative hip-hop ecosystem, is arguing for permission that should never have to be granted: the right for Black artists to be influenced by philosophy, punk, world politics, and criticism without being accused of betrayal or “trying to be white.”
It works because it flips the burden of explanation. The question isn’t why rap should expand; it’s why anyone wants it fenced in.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|
More Quotes by Saul
Add to List
