"Wine is constant proof that God loves us and loves to see us happy"
About this Quote
Franklin slips a sly grin into theology and calls it civic philosophy. By declaring wine "constant proof" of divine love, he borrows the authority of religion to bless a very earthly pleasure, then pretends the syllogism is airtight. It is not a sermon; it's a permission slip. The joke works because it’s framed like an argument from evidence, the Enlightenment’s favorite posture, while the evidence is just fermented grapes and a good time. Franklin makes piety do the work of indulgence.
The subtext is classic Franklin: suspicion of joyless virtue, impatience with moral scolds, and a faith in moderation that still wants life to feel good. Wine becomes a stand-in for the broader project of the era: a world where reason and appetite can coexist without shame. He’s also quietly American about it. In a culture anxious about temperance and propriety (anxiety that would only harden in the next century), he positions conviviality as not merely acceptable but divinely endorsed. That’s a rhetorical jiu-jitsu move: you can’t easily condemn what’s been rebranded as gratitude.
Context matters, too. Franklin was a diplomat in Europe, immersed in French salons where wit and drink were social infrastructure, not guilty secrets. Calling wine "proof" of God’s love also flatters the listener: if you’re enjoying it, you’re participating in a benevolent design. The line is light, but the intent is serious enough: happiness isn’t a vice to outgrow; it’s a principle to defend.
The subtext is classic Franklin: suspicion of joyless virtue, impatience with moral scolds, and a faith in moderation that still wants life to feel good. Wine becomes a stand-in for the broader project of the era: a world where reason and appetite can coexist without shame. He’s also quietly American about it. In a culture anxious about temperance and propriety (anxiety that would only harden in the next century), he positions conviviality as not merely acceptable but divinely endorsed. That’s a rhetorical jiu-jitsu move: you can’t easily condemn what’s been rebranded as gratitude.
Context matters, too. Franklin was a diplomat in Europe, immersed in French salons where wit and drink were social infrastructure, not guilty secrets. Calling wine "proof" of God’s love also flatters the listener: if you’re enjoying it, you’re participating in a benevolent design. The line is light, but the intent is serious enough: happiness isn’t a vice to outgrow; it’s a principle to defend.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wine |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Benjamin
Add to List






