"With terrorist groups like al Qaeda, you can't learn what you want to learn about their capabilities and their future plans by taking a picture of it, and they've learned not to use the telephone"
About this Quote
The line lands like a rebuke to the technocratic fantasy that national security is mostly a matter of better gadgets. Bob Graham, a senator steeped in the post-9/11 intelligence wars, is pointing at a blunt operational truth: the most expensive surveillance platform in the sky can only capture what is visible or electronically noisy. A clandestine network that moves through couriers, face-to-face meetings, and disciplined tradecraft doesn’t leave the kind of clean “take a picture” evidence Americans find comforting.
The phrasing does a lot of political work. “Taking a picture” isn’t just imagery; it’s a shorthand for the whole remote-control model of intelligence: satellites, drones, signal intercepts, the promise of omniscience from a safe distance. Graham’s subtext is that this model produces a dangerous illusion of certainty. You can count trucks, map compounds, monitor a phone tree. You can’t photograph intent, internal debate, or a plan that exists only in someone’s head until the moment it becomes action.
The kicker - “they’ve learned not to use the telephone” - quietly admits an arms race the U.S. can’t simply outspend. It also nudges the listener toward a policy implication Graham often pressed: you need human intelligence, regional expertise, infiltration, and patient relationship-building, not just more collection. In the early 2000s context, it’s a critique of intelligence priorities that privileged scale and technology over the messy, risky work of understanding people.
The phrasing does a lot of political work. “Taking a picture” isn’t just imagery; it’s a shorthand for the whole remote-control model of intelligence: satellites, drones, signal intercepts, the promise of omniscience from a safe distance. Graham’s subtext is that this model produces a dangerous illusion of certainty. You can count trucks, map compounds, monitor a phone tree. You can’t photograph intent, internal debate, or a plan that exists only in someone’s head until the moment it becomes action.
The kicker - “they’ve learned not to use the telephone” - quietly admits an arms race the U.S. can’t simply outspend. It also nudges the listener toward a policy implication Graham often pressed: you need human intelligence, regional expertise, infiltration, and patient relationship-building, not just more collection. In the early 2000s context, it’s a critique of intelligence priorities that privileged scale and technology over the messy, risky work of understanding people.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Bob
Add to List
