Skip to main content

Daily Inspiration Quote by John Lothrop Motley

"With the Germans, the sovereignty resided in the great assembly of the people"

About this Quote

Motley’s line flatters the ancient Germans while quietly schooling his own century: popular sovereignty isn’t a French novelty or an American export, it’s an old European habit with barbarian roots. Writing as a 19th-century historian steeped in Romantic nationalism, he treats “the Germans” less as a precise ethnographic category than as a usable ancestor - a moral pedigree for modern constitutionalism. The phrase “resided in” does heavy ideological work. Sovereignty becomes a substance with a rightful home, not a negotiable arrangement or a messy contest of power. That rhetorical choice makes the claim feel inevitable, almost natural: the people are the container; legitimacy lives there.

The “great assembly” is equally strategic. It conjures an image of open-air consent, communal deliberation, and collective authority - a democratic tableau that sidesteps the inconvenient realities of hierarchy, coercion, and exclusion that typically accompany early tribal politics. Motley’s subtext isn’t that these assemblies were egalitarian in a modern sense; it’s that the principle of accountability predates kings and bureaucracies. He is building a lineage that can be invoked against absolutism and, just as importantly, against the idea that centralized state power is the default endpoint of history.

There’s also a 19th-century American note beneath the European costume. Motley, writing from a republic still arguing over who “the people” includes, finds in “the Germans” a reassuring origin story: collective governance as ancestral, masculine, and martial - democracy with a sword at its hip.

Quote Details

TopicFreedom
More Quotes by John Add to List
Sovereignty in the Great Assembly of the People Motley Quote
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

USA Flag

John Lothrop Motley (April 15, 1814 - May 29, 1877) was a Historian from USA.

24 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes