"Without Arthur's voice, I never would have enjoyed that success"
About this Quote
Paul Simon’s line reads like gratitude, but it’s also a quiet act of brand maintenance: a superstar redirecting the spotlight to the partnership that helped make him inevitable. By naming “Arthur’s voice,” Simon isn’t praising a vague “collaboration.” He’s pinpointing the one thing that can’t be faked in pop mythology: timbre, presence, the instantly recognizable human instrument that turns good writing into a cultural event.
The context is the Simon & Garfunkel story, where authorship and credit were never simple. Simon was the principal songwriter, the architect; Garfunkel was the sheen, the ache, the cathedral echo that made those songs feel larger than folk-club reportage. “That success” is doing a lot of work here. It suggests the kind of career-altering scale you don’t reach through talent alone, but through a particular alchemy - the way two distinct identities can create a third, more marketable one.
Subtextually, it’s an admission that control has limits. Simon could write “Bridge Over Troubled Water,” but the public didn’t just fall for composition; they fell for the delivery, the emotional authority of Garfunkel’s vocal. The line also softens a notoriously tense dynamic without rewriting it. It concedes dependence without surrendering authorship, framing partnership as an accelerant rather than an equal split.
There’s a mature humility in the phrasing, but also precision: Simon isn’t saying he couldn’t succeed. He’s saying he wouldn’t have succeeded like that. That distinction is where the truth lives, and why it lands.
The context is the Simon & Garfunkel story, where authorship and credit were never simple. Simon was the principal songwriter, the architect; Garfunkel was the sheen, the ache, the cathedral echo that made those songs feel larger than folk-club reportage. “That success” is doing a lot of work here. It suggests the kind of career-altering scale you don’t reach through talent alone, but through a particular alchemy - the way two distinct identities can create a third, more marketable one.
Subtextually, it’s an admission that control has limits. Simon could write “Bridge Over Troubled Water,” but the public didn’t just fall for composition; they fell for the delivery, the emotional authority of Garfunkel’s vocal. The line also softens a notoriously tense dynamic without rewriting it. It concedes dependence without surrendering authorship, framing partnership as an accelerant rather than an equal split.
There’s a mature humility in the phrasing, but also precision: Simon isn’t saying he couldn’t succeed. He’s saying he wouldn’t have succeeded like that. That distinction is where the truth lives, and why it lands.
Quote Details
| Topic | Gratitude |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Paul
Add to List



