"Without sounding pompous, I really do feel that I have a set of standards that I must adhere to, even leaving aside considerations of what the readers expect"
About this Quote
“Without sounding pompous” is the tell: Kellerman knows the modern reader’s allergy to self-regard, so he preemptively disarms it. The sentence performs the very tightrope it describes, trying to claim authority while insisting he’s not claiming authority. That little throat-clearing clause is less humility than social calibration, a way to preserve credibility in a culture that rewards authenticity but punishes earnest self-importance.
What follows is a quiet manifesto about craft and conscience. “A set of standards” frames writing not as inspiration or branding, but as a discipline with rules that exist before the marketplace enters the room. The most loaded phrase is “must adhere to.” This isn’t preference; it’s obligation. He’s describing an internal ethics of work: the line he won’t cross to chase a trend, juice a plot, or flatter an audience.
The kicker is “even leaving aside considerations of what the readers expect.” It’s not anti-reader so much as anti-algorithm. Kellerman’s subtext is that reader expectation is a powerful gravitational force - serial fiction, genre publishing, and review culture all train audiences to want the familiar - but it can’t be the primary compass. Coming from a psychologist, the statement also reads as a boundary-setting move: a refusal to outsource self-evaluation to external validation. Standards become a kind of self-supervision, the internal critic you can live with, long after the applause (or backlash) passes.
What follows is a quiet manifesto about craft and conscience. “A set of standards” frames writing not as inspiration or branding, but as a discipline with rules that exist before the marketplace enters the room. The most loaded phrase is “must adhere to.” This isn’t preference; it’s obligation. He’s describing an internal ethics of work: the line he won’t cross to chase a trend, juice a plot, or flatter an audience.
The kicker is “even leaving aside considerations of what the readers expect.” It’s not anti-reader so much as anti-algorithm. Kellerman’s subtext is that reader expectation is a powerful gravitational force - serial fiction, genre publishing, and review culture all train audiences to want the familiar - but it can’t be the primary compass. Coming from a psychologist, the statement also reads as a boundary-setting move: a refusal to outsource self-evaluation to external validation. Standards become a kind of self-supervision, the internal critic you can live with, long after the applause (or backlash) passes.
Quote Details
| Topic | Work Ethic |
|---|
More Quotes by Jonathan
Add to List





