"Writers seldom choose as friends those self-contained characters who are never in trouble, never unhappy or ill, never make mistakes and always count their change when it is handed to them"
About this Quote
Writers don’t befriend perfectionists because perfection is a dead end. Bowen’s line needles the tidy, self-sufficient type: the person who never spills, never spirals, never misreads a room, never even forgets to check the coins in their palm. It’s a deliberately petty detail, “always count their change,” that makes the critique bite. She isn’t talking about virtue; she’s talking about control, a personality so sealed off that nothing gets in and nothing interesting leaks out.
The intent is half social observation, half defense of the messy human. Writers, Bowen implies, are professional eavesdroppers on instability. Trouble, illness, mistakes, unhappiness: these aren’t just plot fuel; they’re the moments when character becomes visible. Crisis forces confession. Error reveals desire. The “self-contained” person offers no access point, no crack where vulnerability might show, no narrative friction. As a friend, they may be reliable. As a subject, they’re inert.
Bowen wrote biography and narrative history, genres built on the premise that public lives are best understood through private flaws and pressure points. In that context, the quote reads like a credo: she’s suspicious of self-mythologizers and drawn to the people who can’t quite keep their stories neat. There’s also a quiet ethics here. By choosing the imperfect as companions, the writer trains her eye toward compassion without sentimentality. It’s not that misery is glamorous; it’s that immaculate competence is often a performance, and Bowen is interested in what happens when the performance fails.
The intent is half social observation, half defense of the messy human. Writers, Bowen implies, are professional eavesdroppers on instability. Trouble, illness, mistakes, unhappiness: these aren’t just plot fuel; they’re the moments when character becomes visible. Crisis forces confession. Error reveals desire. The “self-contained” person offers no access point, no crack where vulnerability might show, no narrative friction. As a friend, they may be reliable. As a subject, they’re inert.
Bowen wrote biography and narrative history, genres built on the premise that public lives are best understood through private flaws and pressure points. In that context, the quote reads like a credo: she’s suspicious of self-mythologizers and drawn to the people who can’t quite keep their stories neat. There’s also a quiet ethics here. By choosing the imperfect as companions, the writer trains her eye toward compassion without sentimentality. It’s not that misery is glamorous; it’s that immaculate competence is often a performance, and Bowen is interested in what happens when the performance fails.
Quote Details
| Topic | Friendship |
|---|
More Quotes by Catherine
Add to List
