"Writing books is the closest men ever come to childbearing"
About this Quote
Mailer’s line is a provocation dressed up as a compliment to art: it flatters the novelist’s labor by borrowing the most mythic form of labor there is. The sting is in the borrowing. By calling book-writing the closest men get to childbearing, he’s not merely praising creativity; he’s staking a claim for male significance in a realm where biology excludes them. It’s an anxious comparison, not an innocent one.
The intent is double. On one level, it elevates writing into something bodily and consequential, pushing back against the idea that books are just talk on paper. On another, it subtly recenters men: even when acknowledging women’s unique experience, he uses it as a measuring stick for male achievement. The subtext reads like a dare to take the novelist’s pain seriously - deadlines as contractions, drafts as miscarriages, publication as delivery. It’s swagger, but it’s also a confession that art-making can feel like the only “creation” a man can claim without apology.
Context matters: Mailer came up in a mid-century literary culture that prized virility, conquest, and the public performance of genius. He often wrote as if masculinity itself were on trial, and this aphorism keeps that courtroom drama alive. It works because it’s blunt, funny, and slightly indecent - a one-sentence argument about envy, legacy, and the male writer’s desire to turn private struggle into a kind of birthright.
The intent is double. On one level, it elevates writing into something bodily and consequential, pushing back against the idea that books are just talk on paper. On another, it subtly recenters men: even when acknowledging women’s unique experience, he uses it as a measuring stick for male achievement. The subtext reads like a dare to take the novelist’s pain seriously - deadlines as contractions, drafts as miscarriages, publication as delivery. It’s swagger, but it’s also a confession that art-making can feel like the only “creation” a man can claim without apology.
Context matters: Mailer came up in a mid-century literary culture that prized virility, conquest, and the public performance of genius. He often wrote as if masculinity itself were on trial, and this aphorism keeps that courtroom drama alive. It works because it’s blunt, funny, and slightly indecent - a one-sentence argument about envy, legacy, and the male writer’s desire to turn private struggle into a kind of birthright.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Norman Mailer , quote listed on his Wikiquote entry ("Writing books is the closest men ever come to childbearing"); primary work/year not given on that page. |
More Quotes by Norman
Add to List
