"Writing free verse is like playing tennis with the net down"
About this Quote
Frost’s line lands with the clean snap of a put-down, but it’s more than a cranky traditionalist swatting at the new kids. “Tennis with the net down” is a deliberately domestic metaphor: a genteel sport, familiar rules, and a single removed constraint that suddenly makes the whole activity feel unserious. Frost isn’t arguing that free verse is effortless; he’s accusing it of forfeiting the very condition that turns effort into craft. The net is form: meter, rhyme, patterned expectation. Without it, you can still hit a ball, even hit it hard, but you’re no longer playing the same game.
The subtext is competitive and territorial. Early 20th-century poetry was in the middle of a legitimacy fight as modernists pushed against inherited forms. Frost, who often wrote in traditional meters while sounding conversational, wanted to keep the old apparatus but avoid sounding old-fashioned. So the jab does double duty: it polices standards while positioning him as the poet who can make “rules” feel like speech, not ceremony. He’s not defending stiffness; he’s defending resistance.
There’s also a canny rhetorical move here: he turns an aesthetic debate into a fairness debate. A lowered net implies cheating, an uneven match, a rigged scoring system. That framing makes free verse seem not just different but evasive, as if it wants applause without agreed-upon difficulty. Of course, modern readers know free verse has its own nets (line breaks, rhythm, structure-by-absence). Frost’s insult works anyway because it flatters our suspicion that art without visible constraints is trying to get away with something.
The subtext is competitive and territorial. Early 20th-century poetry was in the middle of a legitimacy fight as modernists pushed against inherited forms. Frost, who often wrote in traditional meters while sounding conversational, wanted to keep the old apparatus but avoid sounding old-fashioned. So the jab does double duty: it polices standards while positioning him as the poet who can make “rules” feel like speech, not ceremony. He’s not defending stiffness; he’s defending resistance.
There’s also a canny rhetorical move here: he turns an aesthetic debate into a fairness debate. A lowered net implies cheating, an uneven match, a rigged scoring system. That framing makes free verse seem not just different but evasive, as if it wants applause without agreed-upon difficulty. Of course, modern readers know free verse has its own nets (line breaks, rhythm, structure-by-absence). Frost’s insult works anyway because it flatters our suspicion that art without visible constraints is trying to get away with something.
Quote Details
| Topic | Poetry |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
