"Writing is conscience, scruple, and the farming of our ancestors"
About this Quote
Writing, for Dahlberg, isn’t self-expression; it’s self-indictment. “Conscience” and “scruple” yank literature out of the salon and into the moral dock. He’s not praising the novelist as a sensitive soul, but as a person condemned to notice, to judge, to feel the sting of complicity. The phrasing is stiff on purpose: conscience is heavy, scruple is fussy, almost Puritan. It suggests a craft built less on inspiration than on restraint and refusal: refusing easy lies, refusing style as anesthesia.
Then he swerves into the seemingly pastoral: “the farming of our ancestors.” That’s not nostalgia; it’s a corrective. Dahlberg’s subtext is that modern writing has gotten too untethered from labor, consequence, and lineage. Farming is repetitive, bodily, seasonal, and unglamorous. You don’t “disrupt” a field; you tend it, you inherit it, you ruin it if you cut corners. By pairing moral vocabulary with agrarian work, he casts writing as stewardship: language as soil that can be depleted by vanity or enriched by discipline.
Context matters. Dahlberg came up out of poverty, wrote against the grain of American boosterism, and distrusted literary professionalism. The line reads like an attack on writers who treat art as careerist performance. He’s insisting that serious prose should carry the pressure of history: not just the private psyche, but ancestral memory and the ethics of making something that will outlast you. Writing, in this view, is not a mirror. It’s a ledger.
Then he swerves into the seemingly pastoral: “the farming of our ancestors.” That’s not nostalgia; it’s a corrective. Dahlberg’s subtext is that modern writing has gotten too untethered from labor, consequence, and lineage. Farming is repetitive, bodily, seasonal, and unglamorous. You don’t “disrupt” a field; you tend it, you inherit it, you ruin it if you cut corners. By pairing moral vocabulary with agrarian work, he casts writing as stewardship: language as soil that can be depleted by vanity or enriched by discipline.
Context matters. Dahlberg came up out of poverty, wrote against the grain of American boosterism, and distrusted literary professionalism. The line reads like an attack on writers who treat art as careerist performance. He’s insisting that serious prose should carry the pressure of history: not just the private psyche, but ancestral memory and the ethics of making something that will outlast you. Writing, in this view, is not a mirror. It’s a ledger.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List





