"Writing is finally play, and there's no reason why you should get paid for playing"
About this Quote
Irwin Shaw’s line lands like a dare to the professional writer: if you’re treating the page as a job ticket, you’ve already lost the plot. Calling writing “finally play” isn’t a cute metaphor; it’s a value judgment about what makes prose alive. Play means risk, improvisation, and a willingness to look slightly foolish on the way to something true. It’s the opposite of dutiful production. Shaw, who moved between prestige fiction, Hollywood screenwriting, and the churn of mid-century publishing, knew exactly how quickly “the work” can harden into content.
The kicker is the mock-puritan swipe: “there’s no reason why you should get paid for playing.” He’s not arguing against payment so much as puncturing entitlement. Money, in his framing, is a corrupting narrative writers tell themselves: if it’s labor, you deserve compensation; if it’s play, you’re lucky anyone lets you do it. That’s strategic self-defense. It keeps the ego from inflating on advances and reviews, and it keeps the fear from paralyzing you when the market shrugs. If you’re “just playing,” failure stings less, and experimentation becomes permissible again.
There’s also a coded critique of the cultural economy that fetishizes suffering artists. Shaw flips it: the problem isn’t that writing hurts; it’s that writers sometimes want the moral authority of hardship while doing something intrinsically absorbing. The line insists on a craft ethic that’s almost childlike: take the work seriously, but don’t sanctify it. The best writing, he implies, is made by someone willing to mess around until it turns into art.
The kicker is the mock-puritan swipe: “there’s no reason why you should get paid for playing.” He’s not arguing against payment so much as puncturing entitlement. Money, in his framing, is a corrupting narrative writers tell themselves: if it’s labor, you deserve compensation; if it’s play, you’re lucky anyone lets you do it. That’s strategic self-defense. It keeps the ego from inflating on advances and reviews, and it keeps the fear from paralyzing you when the market shrugs. If you’re “just playing,” failure stings less, and experimentation becomes permissible again.
There’s also a coded critique of the cultural economy that fetishizes suffering artists. Shaw flips it: the problem isn’t that writing hurts; it’s that writers sometimes want the moral authority of hardship while doing something intrinsically absorbing. The line insists on a craft ethic that’s almost childlike: take the work seriously, but don’t sanctify it. The best writing, he implies, is made by someone willing to mess around until it turns into art.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Irwin
Add to List
