"Ye are brothers, ye are men, and we conquer but to save"
About this Quote
“Ye are brothers, ye are men, and we conquer but to save” is war-language laundered into moral language, and that’s precisely why it lands. Campbell, a Romantic-era poet writing in an age of revolutions and imperial campaigns, offers a line that sounds like a rallying cry but behaves like a self-justification. It opens with a sudden insistence on shared humanity - brothers, men - as if naming kinship can retroactively disinfect violence. The phrasing “Ye are” has the cadence of scripture and proclamation, not conversation; it’s designed to grant authority, to make the audience feel drafted into a moral community.
Then comes the hinge: “we conquer but to save.” “But” is doing the heavy lifting, flipping conquest from appetite to obligation. The sentence performs a familiar political magic trick: aggression recast as guardianship. Campbell’s intent isn’t just to praise bravery; it’s to make domination feel reluctant, even tender. “Save” implies rescue, protection, humanitarian necessity - a proto-version of the rhetoric modern states use when they claim to bomb for peace or invade to liberate.
The subtext is anxious: if conquest truly needed no defense, the line wouldn’t argue so hard. By staging conquerors as caretakers, Campbell offers his readers a way to feel righteous inside the machinery of empire and war. It’s Romantic humanism under pressure, trying to keep its ideals intact while history keeps demanding winners.
Then comes the hinge: “we conquer but to save.” “But” is doing the heavy lifting, flipping conquest from appetite to obligation. The sentence performs a familiar political magic trick: aggression recast as guardianship. Campbell’s intent isn’t just to praise bravery; it’s to make domination feel reluctant, even tender. “Save” implies rescue, protection, humanitarian necessity - a proto-version of the rhetoric modern states use when they claim to bomb for peace or invade to liberate.
The subtext is anxious: if conquest truly needed no defense, the line wouldn’t argue so hard. By staging conquerors as caretakers, Campbell offers his readers a way to feel righteous inside the machinery of empire and war. It’s Romantic humanism under pressure, trying to keep its ideals intact while history keeps demanding winners.
Quote Details
| Topic | Peace |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List




