"Yes, Carl Vine stuck around. He's now number one composer for choreography"
About this Quote
There’s a casual flex hidden inside that offhand “Yes.” Murphy isn’t just answering a question; he’s closing a debate. The line reads like backstage talk that accidentally tells the whole story of contemporary dance’s power dynamics: choreographers don’t merely interpret music, they appoint it. “Stuck around” is deceptively loaded. It frames Carl Vine not as an inevitable genius but as someone who survived the churn of commissions, tastes, and artistic politics. In dance, where collaborations can be brutal and temporary, longevity is a credential.
Then Murphy upgrades the survival narrative into a ranking: “number one composer for choreography.” It’s not an official title; it’s an insider’s coronation. The phrasing suggests a field where “best” isn’t about concert halls or critic-proof prestige, but about usability: rhythmic intelligence, emotional contour, and an instinct for bodies in motion. Vine, in this telling, isn’t just composing music; he’s building engines for dancers. Murphy’s compliment is practical, almost managerial: this is the composer who delivers.
The subtext is also territorial. A dancer-choreographer claiming who sits at the top hints at how dance often treats composers as infrastructure, not auteurs. Yet Murphy’s praise pushes back against that invisibility by naming Vine as essential to the art form’s evolution. The remark lands like a bit of gossip with a manifesto inside it: the canon of “serious” composers matters less here than the one that actually moves people, literally.
Then Murphy upgrades the survival narrative into a ranking: “number one composer for choreography.” It’s not an official title; it’s an insider’s coronation. The phrasing suggests a field where “best” isn’t about concert halls or critic-proof prestige, but about usability: rhythmic intelligence, emotional contour, and an instinct for bodies in motion. Vine, in this telling, isn’t just composing music; he’s building engines for dancers. Murphy’s compliment is practical, almost managerial: this is the composer who delivers.
The subtext is also territorial. A dancer-choreographer claiming who sits at the top hints at how dance often treats composers as infrastructure, not auteurs. Yet Murphy’s praise pushes back against that invisibility by naming Vine as essential to the art form’s evolution. The remark lands like a bit of gossip with a manifesto inside it: the canon of “serious” composers matters less here than the one that actually moves people, literally.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Graeme
Add to List