"Yet, analytical truth is not as mysterious, or as secret, so as to not allow us to see that people with a talent for directing consciences see truth rise spontaneously"
About this Quote
Lacan is doing that very Lacanian thing: turning “truth” from a stable object into a performance that happens in a room, between people, under pressure. “Analytical truth” isn’t a hidden treasure the analyst heroically uncovers; it’s less occult than we pretend. The real mystery, he hints, is why we keep acting as if the truth is locked away somewhere deep inside the patient, when analysis repeatedly shows it surfacing on cue.
The barb is aimed at authority. “People with a talent for directing consciences” reads like a deliberately unsettling description of priests, moralists, therapists, and any institutional voice trained to manage guilt and desire. Lacan’s subtext: put someone in a setting where they believe their inner life is being interpreted, and “truth” starts appearing spontaneously, not because it was finally excavated, but because the situation manufactures a demand to confess. Truth rises the way a symptom rises: as an effect of structure, language, and expectation.
This lands in Lacan’s broader project of dethroning the ego and treating speech as the engine of the psyche. In the mid-century psychoanalytic world, “insight” could sound like a scientific revelation or a moral purification. Lacan cuts through that self-congratulation. He’s warning that analysis is dangerously close to pastoral power: it can produce truths by shaping what counts as sayable, forgivable, real.
So the line works as both demystification and accusation. Analysis can be lucid, even mechanical, about how truth emerges. The ethical question is whether the analyst is facilitating desire or quietly directing the conscience.
The barb is aimed at authority. “People with a talent for directing consciences” reads like a deliberately unsettling description of priests, moralists, therapists, and any institutional voice trained to manage guilt and desire. Lacan’s subtext: put someone in a setting where they believe their inner life is being interpreted, and “truth” starts appearing spontaneously, not because it was finally excavated, but because the situation manufactures a demand to confess. Truth rises the way a symptom rises: as an effect of structure, language, and expectation.
This lands in Lacan’s broader project of dethroning the ego and treating speech as the engine of the psyche. In the mid-century psychoanalytic world, “insight” could sound like a scientific revelation or a moral purification. Lacan cuts through that self-congratulation. He’s warning that analysis is dangerously close to pastoral power: it can produce truths by shaping what counts as sayable, forgivable, real.
So the line works as both demystification and accusation. Analysis can be lucid, even mechanical, about how truth emerges. The ethical question is whether the analyst is facilitating desire or quietly directing the conscience.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Jacques
Add to List












