"You British plundered half the world for your own profit. Let's not pass it off as the Age of Enlightenment"
About this Quote
There is no polite way to take empire seriously, Chayefsky implies, without also taking its violence personally. The line is built like a slap: first the blunt charge of material theft ("plundered half the world"), then the moral accounting ("for your own profit"), then the real target - the soothing story we tell afterward. "Let's not pass it off" is theater-speak disguised as debate etiquette: a controlled, almost conversational phrase used to detonate a national self-myth.
Chayefsky, a playwright with a nose for institutional hypocrisy, aims at the rhetorical laundering that turns extraction into ideals. The "Age of Enlightenment" functions here less as a historical period than as a brand name, a respectable label that lets power look principled. By yoking Enlightenment language to plunder, he spotlights the contradiction at the heart of Western self-celebration: liberty and reason preached at home, coercion and commerce enforced abroad. The accusation isn't that Enlightenment thought was fake; it's that invoking it can become a convenient alibi.
The subtext is also about who gets to narrate history. "You British" is a second-person indictment meant to collapse distance - not "the Empire" in abstract, but a living inheritance of prestige, museums, and schoolroom pride. It's an attack on nostalgia as political cover, the kind that treats colonial brutality as a regrettable footnote to a glorious civilizational arc. Chayefsky's intent is to make the footnote the headline, and to make any refined conversation about "progress" feel, for a moment, like complicity.
Chayefsky, a playwright with a nose for institutional hypocrisy, aims at the rhetorical laundering that turns extraction into ideals. The "Age of Enlightenment" functions here less as a historical period than as a brand name, a respectable label that lets power look principled. By yoking Enlightenment language to plunder, he spotlights the contradiction at the heart of Western self-celebration: liberty and reason preached at home, coercion and commerce enforced abroad. The accusation isn't that Enlightenment thought was fake; it's that invoking it can become a convenient alibi.
The subtext is also about who gets to narrate history. "You British" is a second-person indictment meant to collapse distance - not "the Empire" in abstract, but a living inheritance of prestige, museums, and schoolroom pride. It's an attack on nostalgia as political cover, the kind that treats colonial brutality as a regrettable footnote to a glorious civilizational arc. Chayefsky's intent is to make the footnote the headline, and to make any refined conversation about "progress" feel, for a moment, like complicity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Paddy
Add to List