"You can play a shoestring if you're sincere"
About this Quote
Coltrane’s line lands like a rebuke to every gear-obsessed conversation about art: the point isn’t the instrument, it’s the honesty driving it. “Play a shoestring” is funny because it’s impossible and vividly low-rent at the same time; it collapses the whole status hierarchy of music-making into a single image of making-do. He’s not romanticizing poverty so much as stripping away excuses. If sincerity is present, sound will find a way.
The subtext is almost confrontational. Sincerity here isn’t “being nice” or “being vulnerable” in the contemporary branding sense; it’s commitment. It’s the willingness to mean what you play, to push past competence into conviction. Coming from Coltrane, that reads as an ethic: practice like devotion, improvisation as truth-telling. You hear it in his arc from hard bop precision to the searching, spiritual intensity of A Love Supreme and beyond, where the “right” notes matter less than the urgency behind them.
Context matters: mid-century jazz was both virtuoso craft and a battleground over authenticity, race, and commercialization. Studios, labels, and critics often treated musicians as interchangeable stylists while fans fetishized technical flash. Coltrane flips the script. Technical mastery is there, but he refuses to let it be the alibi. The line also defends experimentation: if you’re sincere, even rough sounds or unconventional tools can carry meaning. It’s a compact manifesto for anyone making art under constraints - or hiding behind them.
The subtext is almost confrontational. Sincerity here isn’t “being nice” or “being vulnerable” in the contemporary branding sense; it’s commitment. It’s the willingness to mean what you play, to push past competence into conviction. Coming from Coltrane, that reads as an ethic: practice like devotion, improvisation as truth-telling. You hear it in his arc from hard bop precision to the searching, spiritual intensity of A Love Supreme and beyond, where the “right” notes matter less than the urgency behind them.
Context matters: mid-century jazz was both virtuoso craft and a battleground over authenticity, race, and commercialization. Studios, labels, and critics often treated musicians as interchangeable stylists while fans fetishized technical flash. Coltrane flips the script. Technical mastery is there, but he refuses to let it be the alibi. The line also defends experimentation: if you’re sincere, even rough sounds or unconventional tools can carry meaning. It’s a compact manifesto for anyone making art under constraints - or hiding behind them.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by John
Add to List








