"You cannot set art off in a corner and hope for it to have vitality, reality, and substance"
About this Quote
Ives is taking a swing at the museum-glass version of culture: art treated as a delicate object, quarantined from ordinary life, then praised for being “timeless” precisely because it’s been removed from time. “Set art off in a corner” sounds domestic, almost petty - a painting shoved aside like unwanted furniture. The bite is that the corner doesn’t just isolate; it anesthetizes. Vitality, reality, and substance aren’t qualities you can preserve by protecting them. They’re qualities you generate by friction: with commerce, politics, noise, faith, gossip, labor, bad taste, and the mess of being alive.
That subtext tracks with Ives’s whole biography and aesthetic. He wasn’t a conservatory lifer polishing prestige; he was a working insurance executive who wrote music that collaged hymns, marching bands, parlor songs, and dissonant experiments into something that sounded like America overhearing itself. His point isn’t “art should be popular” so much as “art should be in contact.” The concert hall’s solemn hush, the gatekeeping around “serious” music, the idea of culture as a separate, elevated zone - all of it risks producing art that is technically correct and spiritually evacuated.
The line also reads as a warning to audiences and institutions: don’t ask art to behave, to be decorous, to stay put. If you want it to feel real, you have to let it contend with real life, including the parts that make patrons uncomfortable.
That subtext tracks with Ives’s whole biography and aesthetic. He wasn’t a conservatory lifer polishing prestige; he was a working insurance executive who wrote music that collaged hymns, marching bands, parlor songs, and dissonant experiments into something that sounded like America overhearing itself. His point isn’t “art should be popular” so much as “art should be in contact.” The concert hall’s solemn hush, the gatekeeping around “serious” music, the idea of culture as a separate, elevated zone - all of it risks producing art that is technically correct and spiritually evacuated.
The line also reads as a warning to audiences and institutions: don’t ask art to behave, to be decorous, to stay put. If you want it to feel real, you have to let it contend with real life, including the parts that make patrons uncomfortable.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List
