"You do not have to do everything disagreeable that you have a right to do"
About this Quote
Freedom is a lousy excuse for bad manners, and Judith Martin knows it. "You do not have to do everything disagreeable that you have a right to do" is a neat little trap laid for the modern habit of confusing entitlement with virtue. The line doesn’t argue against rights; it argues against the adolescent fantasy that rights are a personality. Martin, as "Miss Manners", built a career insisting that social life isn’t held together by legal permission slips but by voluntary restraint: the unglamorous choice to not weaponize your options.
The intent is corrective, almost parental, but the subtext is sharper. It rebukes a culture that treats bluntness as authenticity, selfishness as self-care, and antagonism as courage. The sentence turns on that pivot between "have a right" and "have to". Rights mark the outer boundary of what you may do; etiquette asks what you should do if you want to remain in civilization’s good graces. Martin’s genius is framing politeness not as deference to the powerful, but as discipline for everyone - including the person who could, technically, get away with being awful.
Context matters: Martin emerged as an advice columnist in late-20th-century America, an era increasingly suspicious of "rules" and hungry for personal expression. Her retort is that the absence of rules doesn’t produce liberation; it produces friction. Courtesy, here, isn’t ornamental. It’s the social technology that keeps everyday life from collapsing into a series of petty, fully-legal cruelties.
The intent is corrective, almost parental, but the subtext is sharper. It rebukes a culture that treats bluntness as authenticity, selfishness as self-care, and antagonism as courage. The sentence turns on that pivot between "have a right" and "have to". Rights mark the outer boundary of what you may do; etiquette asks what you should do if you want to remain in civilization’s good graces. Martin’s genius is framing politeness not as deference to the powerful, but as discipline for everyone - including the person who could, technically, get away with being awful.
Context matters: Martin emerged as an advice columnist in late-20th-century America, an era increasingly suspicious of "rules" and hungry for personal expression. Her retort is that the absence of rules doesn’t produce liberation; it produces friction. Courtesy, here, isn’t ornamental. It’s the social technology that keeps everyday life from collapsing into a series of petty, fully-legal cruelties.
Quote Details
| Topic | Kindness |
|---|
More Quotes by Judith
Add to List
