"You find yourself in the world, without any power, immovable as a rock, stupid, so to speak, as a log of wood"
About this Quote
Dropped into existence like dead weight: Malebranche’s line is a deliberately humiliating self-portrait of the human creature, designed to puncture the ego before theology rushes in to fill the vacuum. The piling-on of insults - “without any power,” “immovable as a rock,” “stupid…as a log of wood” - isn’t casual cruelty; it’s philosophical stagecraft. He wants the reader to feel, bodily, the scandal of impotence. You don’t reason your way into dependence on God; you’re shoved into it.
Context matters. Malebranche is a 17th-century French Cartesian trying to reconcile Descartes’ new machinery of mind-and-matter with an Augustinian obsession: God as the only real source of causation. His occasionalism argues that created things don’t truly cause anything; they’re occasions for God’s action. The quote dramatizes that metaphysics in the register of embarrassment. If you are “immovable,” it’s because your will cannot move the world by itself. If you are “stupid,” it’s because your perceptions aren’t self-grounding; you “see” truths only in God.
The subtext is polemical: against self-sufficient rationalism, against the cozy moral story that you steer your life through sheer inner force. Malebranche isn’t just calling you weak; he’s calling the modern subject a fraud. The rhetorical trick is the coarse simile - rock, log - material objects, the very stuff Descartes said was inert. Malebranche borrows that inertness and pins it on the human who thought he was sovereign, making humility not a virtue but a starting condition.
Context matters. Malebranche is a 17th-century French Cartesian trying to reconcile Descartes’ new machinery of mind-and-matter with an Augustinian obsession: God as the only real source of causation. His occasionalism argues that created things don’t truly cause anything; they’re occasions for God’s action. The quote dramatizes that metaphysics in the register of embarrassment. If you are “immovable,” it’s because your will cannot move the world by itself. If you are “stupid,” it’s because your perceptions aren’t self-grounding; you “see” truths only in God.
The subtext is polemical: against self-sufficient rationalism, against the cozy moral story that you steer your life through sheer inner force. Malebranche isn’t just calling you weak; he’s calling the modern subject a fraud. The rhetorical trick is the coarse simile - rock, log - material objects, the very stuff Descartes said was inert. Malebranche borrows that inertness and pins it on the human who thought he was sovereign, making humility not a virtue but a starting condition.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|
More Quotes by Nicolas
Add to List
