"You happen to be talking to an agnostic. You know what an agnostic is? A cowardly atheist"
About this Quote
Terkel’s jab lands because it’s aimed less at theology than at temperament. Calling an agnostic a “cowardly atheist” turns a supposedly humble position of uncertainty into a social tell: not a careful thinker suspended between evidence, but someone who already knows where they stand and lacks the nerve to say it out loud. It’s a line with the snap of a street argument, but also the shrewdness of a veteran interviewer who spent a lifetime listening for evasions.
The intent is provocation. Terkel isn’t building a syllogism; he’s trying to smoke out a posture. In American public life, “atheist” has long functioned as a cultural scarlet letter, while “agnostic” offers plausible deniability - an identity that can pass in mixed company. By framing agnosticism as cowardice, he flips the usual moral hierarchy. Doubt, often admired as intellectual sophistication, becomes a kind of reputational risk-management. The insult works because it’s legible: everyone recognizes the social reflex to soften a taboo claim into something more palatable.
The subtext is also about class and plain speech. Terkel’s populist sensibility mistrusted genteel hedging, especially when it served comfort rather than accuracy. As a journalist of working voices and hard realities, he’s suspicious of positions that keep you safe from consequences. It’s a moralizing quip, yes, but it doubles as cultural reportage: in a country where belief is performative and unbelief is punishable, even uncertainty can be a mask.
The intent is provocation. Terkel isn’t building a syllogism; he’s trying to smoke out a posture. In American public life, “atheist” has long functioned as a cultural scarlet letter, while “agnostic” offers plausible deniability - an identity that can pass in mixed company. By framing agnosticism as cowardice, he flips the usual moral hierarchy. Doubt, often admired as intellectual sophistication, becomes a kind of reputational risk-management. The insult works because it’s legible: everyone recognizes the social reflex to soften a taboo claim into something more palatable.
The subtext is also about class and plain speech. Terkel’s populist sensibility mistrusted genteel hedging, especially when it served comfort rather than accuracy. As a journalist of working voices and hard realities, he’s suspicious of positions that keep you safe from consequences. It’s a moralizing quip, yes, but it doubles as cultural reportage: in a country where belief is performative and unbelief is punishable, even uncertainty can be a mask.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sarcastic |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Studs
Add to List





