"You have to feel more involved than just writing out a cheque. Charity is almost the wrong word - I think people are beginning to feel more responsible for the world"
About this Quote
Lumley’s line lands because it gently shames a familiar modern habit: outsourcing conscience to a payment. “Writing out a cheque” is deliberately mundane, the smallest possible gesture that still buys the warm glow of having “done something.” By framing that as insufficient, she’s not attacking giving; she’s attacking the transactional mindset that turns compassion into a receipt.
Her key move is linguistic: “Charity is almost the wrong word.” Charity sounds optional, seasonal, even paternalistic - a benevolent extra bestowed by the comfortable. Lumley nudges us toward a harder frame: responsibility. Responsibility implies obligation, proximity, and follow-through. It’s about being implicated, not just being kind. In a celebrity culture where public virtue can be performed with a donation and an Instagram caption, she’s arguing for a thicker form of engagement: time, attention, advocacy, political pressure, maybe discomfort.
The subtext is also about power. Cheques preserve distance. They let donors remain untroubled by the systems that produced the need in the first place. “More involved” hints at a shift from relief to accountability: not simply helping victims of a problem, but confronting the machinery behind it. That’s why the last clause matters: “people are beginning to feel more responsible for the world.” She’s describing an emerging moral weather change - from philanthropy as personal virtue to global citizenship as a social expectation. It’s a hopeful diagnosis, but it’s also a dare: if you claim to care, show it in ways that can’t be cashed and forgotten.
Her key move is linguistic: “Charity is almost the wrong word.” Charity sounds optional, seasonal, even paternalistic - a benevolent extra bestowed by the comfortable. Lumley nudges us toward a harder frame: responsibility. Responsibility implies obligation, proximity, and follow-through. It’s about being implicated, not just being kind. In a celebrity culture where public virtue can be performed with a donation and an Instagram caption, she’s arguing for a thicker form of engagement: time, attention, advocacy, political pressure, maybe discomfort.
The subtext is also about power. Cheques preserve distance. They let donors remain untroubled by the systems that produced the need in the first place. “More involved” hints at a shift from relief to accountability: not simply helping victims of a problem, but confronting the machinery behind it. That’s why the last clause matters: “people are beginning to feel more responsible for the world.” She’s describing an emerging moral weather change - from philanthropy as personal virtue to global citizenship as a social expectation. It’s a hopeful diagnosis, but it’s also a dare: if you claim to care, show it in ways that can’t be cashed and forgotten.
Quote Details
| Topic | Kindness |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Joanna
Add to List





