"You have to make a choice when you start to sing and decide whether you want to service the music, and be at the top of your art, or if you want to be a very popular tenor"
About this Quote
Kraus slips a knife into the soft myth that popularity is proof of excellence. Framed as practical advice to a young singer, the line is really a values test: at the moment you open your mouth, you’re not just choosing repertoire or technique, you’re choosing who you’re accountable to. “Service the music” casts the singer as a steward, not a star. The goal isn’t audience approval, but fidelity to the score, style, and tradition - the unglamorous discipline that keeps an art form from collapsing into easy thrills.
The sting lands in that loaded phrase “very popular tenor.” Kraus isn’t denying that crowds can be right; he’s warning how quickly the market trains a voice. Chasing applause nudges singers toward bigger, blunter effects: safer interpretive choices, repertoire that flatters the instrument now, not what will sustain it later, shortcuts that sell “emotion” without the hard-earned nuance that creates it. In opera, that temptation is structural. A thrilling high note is instantly legible; taste, line, and restraint are harder to monetize.
Context matters: Kraus built a reputation on elegance, precision, and longevity, resisting the pressure to sing heavier roles that could have delivered faster hype and faster damage. His comment is also a quiet rebuke to a celebrity culture that turns vocal art into personal branding. The subtext is almost moral: if you treat music as something you use, it will use you back. If you serve it, you might never become “very popular,” but you earn something rarer - authority that outlasts a season of cheers.
The sting lands in that loaded phrase “very popular tenor.” Kraus isn’t denying that crowds can be right; he’s warning how quickly the market trains a voice. Chasing applause nudges singers toward bigger, blunter effects: safer interpretive choices, repertoire that flatters the instrument now, not what will sustain it later, shortcuts that sell “emotion” without the hard-earned nuance that creates it. In opera, that temptation is structural. A thrilling high note is instantly legible; taste, line, and restraint are harder to monetize.
Context matters: Kraus built a reputation on elegance, precision, and longevity, resisting the pressure to sing heavier roles that could have delivered faster hype and faster damage. His comment is also a quiet rebuke to a celebrity culture that turns vocal art into personal branding. The subtext is almost moral: if you treat music as something you use, it will use you back. If you serve it, you might never become “very popular,” but you earn something rarer - authority that outlasts a season of cheers.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Alfredo
Add to List


