"You know how much I am inclined to explain all disputes among philosophical schools as merely verbal disputes or at least to derive them originally from verbal disputes"
About this Quote
Mendelssohn is admitting a bias that’s almost a method: when philosophers start swinging at each other, he reaches first for the dictionary. The line has the quiet sting of Enlightenment impatience with metaphysical theatrics. He’s not denying that real disagreements exist; he’s suggesting that many of them begin life as a mishandled term, a sloppy definition, a word doing double duty without anyone noticing. That “inclined” is key. It signals temperament as much as argument: a thinker trained to suspect that heat in a debate often comes from language pretending to be substance.
The subtext is also polemical. In the 18th-century German scene, rival schools were busy hardening into camps, each with its preferred vocabulary and prestige dialect. By reframing disputes as “merely verbal,” Mendelssohn undercuts the authority of factional jargon and re-centers clarity as a philosophical virtue. It’s an offer of peace, but not a neutral one. If your system can’t survive paraphrase, he implies, maybe it wasn’t knowledge so much as branding.
Context matters: Mendelssohn sits at the hinge between Jewish intellectual life and the broader European Enlightenment, where translation, interpretation, and public reason were not abstract issues but daily practice. His remark reads like an ethic of communication: philosophy should make its concepts accountable to common understanding. The line works because it’s both deflationary and hopeful - a wager that many “deep” problems become tractable once we stop letting words masquerade as discoveries.
The subtext is also polemical. In the 18th-century German scene, rival schools were busy hardening into camps, each with its preferred vocabulary and prestige dialect. By reframing disputes as “merely verbal,” Mendelssohn undercuts the authority of factional jargon and re-centers clarity as a philosophical virtue. It’s an offer of peace, but not a neutral one. If your system can’t survive paraphrase, he implies, maybe it wasn’t knowledge so much as branding.
Context matters: Mendelssohn sits at the hinge between Jewish intellectual life and the broader European Enlightenment, where translation, interpretation, and public reason were not abstract issues but daily practice. His remark reads like an ethic of communication: philosophy should make its concepts accountable to common understanding. The line works because it’s both deflationary and hopeful - a wager that many “deep” problems become tractable once we stop letting words masquerade as discoveries.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Moses
Add to List








