"You know, if you really want to fiddle the old-time way, you've got to learn the dance. The contra-dances, hoedowns. It's all in the rhythm of the bow. The great North Carolina fiddle player Tommy Jarrell said, 'If a feller can't bow, he'll never make a fiddler. He might make a violin player, but he'll never make no fiddler.'"
About this Quote
Old-time music doesn’t let you hide behind prettiness. Alison Krauss is drawing a bright line between “violin” as a polished, concert-hall identity and “fiddle” as a functional, community tool built to move bodies. Her key move is to anchor virtuosity not in speed or ornament, but in dance literacy: if you don’t understand contra-dances and hoedowns, you don’t understand what the music is for. The point isn’t nostalgia; it’s accountability. Old-time playing is judged by whether it locks into the dancers’ feet, whether the bow carries a pulse strong enough to organize a room.
The subtext is a quiet rebuke to a modern music economy that rewards surface: clean tone, studio sheen, technique as résumé. Krauss, a crossover star with impeccable chops, is essentially saying that technique can be a cul-de-sac. Without bow rhythm - that gritty, engine-room groove - you’re speaking the right language with the wrong accent. That’s why she borrows Tommy Jarrell’s blunt Appalachian gatekeeping: it’s not elitism so much as a cultural safeguard, a way of keeping tradition from being museumified into “heritage aesthetics.”
Context matters here. Krauss comes out of bluegrass and old-time worlds that have been repackaged for festivals and recordings. By insisting on dance as the classroom, she re-centers the music’s original venue: not the stage, but the floor. The bow becomes more than a tool for pitch; it’s the drum, the breath, the social contract.
The subtext is a quiet rebuke to a modern music economy that rewards surface: clean tone, studio sheen, technique as résumé. Krauss, a crossover star with impeccable chops, is essentially saying that technique can be a cul-de-sac. Without bow rhythm - that gritty, engine-room groove - you’re speaking the right language with the wrong accent. That’s why she borrows Tommy Jarrell’s blunt Appalachian gatekeeping: it’s not elitism so much as a cultural safeguard, a way of keeping tradition from being museumified into “heritage aesthetics.”
Context matters here. Krauss comes out of bluegrass and old-time worlds that have been repackaged for festivals and recordings. By insisting on dance as the classroom, she re-centers the music’s original venue: not the stage, but the floor. The bow becomes more than a tool for pitch; it’s the drum, the breath, the social contract.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Alison
Add to List







