"You may depend upon it that they are as good hearts to serve men in palaces as in cottages"
About this Quote
Owen’s line is a quiet grenade lobbed into a class system that loved to call itself “natural.” The phrasing is politely confident, almost conversational - “You may depend upon it” - but the target is blunt: the assumption that moral worth and human capacity somehow rise with rent prices. He’s not romanticizing poverty; he’s stripping away the alibi that lets elites treat workers as a different species.
The craft is in the contrast: “palaces” and “cottages” aren’t just buildings, they’re moral stages in 19th-century imagination. By insisting that “good hearts” exist in both, Owen reframes service - the most literal expression of hierarchy - as evidence of shared humanity rather than proof of inferiority. It’s also a tactical appeal to the very people who benefit from the system: he speaks in their language of virtue and duty, then redirects it toward an uncomfortable conclusion. If servants possess “good hearts,” then exploitation becomes not only inefficient but indecent.
Context matters. Owen wasn’t a distant moralizer; he ran mills and became famous for New Lanark, where improved working conditions were paired with a belief that character is shaped by environment. The subtext is proto-socialist and managerial at once: treat people well and they will meet you with competence, loyalty, even affection - not because they’re naturally “better,” but because the conditions stop crushing them. In an era of industrial brutality, that’s both humane and strategically disruptive.
The craft is in the contrast: “palaces” and “cottages” aren’t just buildings, they’re moral stages in 19th-century imagination. By insisting that “good hearts” exist in both, Owen reframes service - the most literal expression of hierarchy - as evidence of shared humanity rather than proof of inferiority. It’s also a tactical appeal to the very people who benefit from the system: he speaks in their language of virtue and duty, then redirects it toward an uncomfortable conclusion. If servants possess “good hearts,” then exploitation becomes not only inefficient but indecent.
Context matters. Owen wasn’t a distant moralizer; he ran mills and became famous for New Lanark, where improved working conditions were paired with a belief that character is shaped by environment. The subtext is proto-socialist and managerial at once: treat people well and they will meet you with competence, loyalty, even affection - not because they’re naturally “better,” but because the conditions stop crushing them. In an era of industrial brutality, that’s both humane and strategically disruptive.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
