"You may have a fresh start any moment you choose, for this thing that we call "failure" is not the falling down, but the staying down"
About this Quote
Pickford’s line reads like a pep talk, but it’s really a piece of hard-earned brand engineering from a woman who had to keep reinventing herself in public. As “America’s Sweetheart” and a founding force behind United Artists, she lived in an industry that sold illusion while punishing vulnerability. So she reframes “failure” with a performer’s pragmatism: falling is inevitable; what matters is whether you can hit your mark again when the lights come back up.
The intent is motivational, yes, but the subtext is more strategic. By defining failure as “staying down,” Pickford shifts the moral weight away from the mistake and onto the response. That’s a liberating move in a culture that loves to treat setbacks as character verdicts. It also quietly assigns agency to the individual: a “fresh start” isn’t granted by gatekeepers, critics, or fate; it’s chosen. In Hollywood terms, your comeback isn’t a miracle, it’s a decision plus work.
The phrasing does extra work. “This thing that we call ‘failure’” puts the concept in quotation marks without using them: failure is a label, a social story, not a physical law. And the sentence rhythm pivots on a simple contrast - “not the falling down, but the staying down” - a clean bit of rhetoric that sounds like common sense because it is.
Context matters: Pickford’s era idolized resilience while offering women little room to age, err, or change. Her quote isn’t naive optimism; it’s survival advice for anyone being watched.
The intent is motivational, yes, but the subtext is more strategic. By defining failure as “staying down,” Pickford shifts the moral weight away from the mistake and onto the response. That’s a liberating move in a culture that loves to treat setbacks as character verdicts. It also quietly assigns agency to the individual: a “fresh start” isn’t granted by gatekeepers, critics, or fate; it’s chosen. In Hollywood terms, your comeback isn’t a miracle, it’s a decision plus work.
The phrasing does extra work. “This thing that we call ‘failure’” puts the concept in quotation marks without using them: failure is a label, a social story, not a physical law. And the sentence rhythm pivots on a simple contrast - “not the falling down, but the staying down” - a clean bit of rhetoric that sounds like common sense because it is.
Context matters: Pickford’s era idolized resilience while offering women little room to age, err, or change. Her quote isn’t naive optimism; it’s survival advice for anyone being watched.
Quote Details
| Topic | Never Give Up |
|---|
More Quotes by Mary
Add to List







