"You never know when you're going to be considered un-hip... The people that really pass judgment on you really have nothing to do with what you do, usually"
About this Quote
Milius is skewering the teen-magazine version of cultural power: the idea that “hip” is a stable crown, awarded by the people who matter. His phrasing turns coolness into an ambush. “You never know when” suggests a trapdoor you didn’t see because you were busy working. In his world, un-hipness isn’t earned; it’s assigned, often retroactively, once the room’s temperature changes.
The second line is the real tell: judgment comes from people “that really have nothing to do with what you do.” That’s Hollywood and the wider culture industry in a nutshell - a marketplace where reception is outsourced to spectators, columnists, gatekeepers, trend-miners, and rivals whose authority is vibes, not craft. Milius isn’t pretending artists should be immune to criticism; he’s pointing out the mismatch between who makes the work and who gets to narrate its meaning, relevance, and moral status.
Context matters because Milius is a director-screenwriter associated with a specific strain of American masculinity and swagger (from co-writing Apocalypse Now to directing Conan the Barbarian). His sensibility drifted in and out of fashion as politics, taste, and the industry’s self-image shifted. The quote reads like a survival note from someone who’s watched reputations get re-priced overnight: not by the set, not by the audience in any deep sense, but by the commentary layer that hovers above the work and rarely sweats the details. It’s less bitterness than a warning: don’t confuse the noise around art with the art’s actual value.
The second line is the real tell: judgment comes from people “that really have nothing to do with what you do.” That’s Hollywood and the wider culture industry in a nutshell - a marketplace where reception is outsourced to spectators, columnists, gatekeepers, trend-miners, and rivals whose authority is vibes, not craft. Milius isn’t pretending artists should be immune to criticism; he’s pointing out the mismatch between who makes the work and who gets to narrate its meaning, relevance, and moral status.
Context matters because Milius is a director-screenwriter associated with a specific strain of American masculinity and swagger (from co-writing Apocalypse Now to directing Conan the Barbarian). His sensibility drifted in and out of fashion as politics, taste, and the industry’s self-image shifted. The quote reads like a survival note from someone who’s watched reputations get re-priced overnight: not by the set, not by the audience in any deep sense, but by the commentary layer that hovers above the work and rarely sweats the details. It’s less bitterness than a warning: don’t confuse the noise around art with the art’s actual value.
Quote Details
| Topic | Confidence |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List






